New York City’s dining scene is a living, breathing organism, constantly shifting with new openings and reimagined classics. When it comes to Italian food, the sheer volume of options can feel overwhelming, ranging from corner slice joints to white-tablecloth institutions.
Finding a truly memorable meal requires looking beyond the tourist traps and into the neighborhoods where Nonna’s recipes meet modern culinary innovation. This guide cuts through the noise to highlight the establishments that define Italian excellence in the five boroughs.
The definition of “best” in New York is subjective, often depending on whether you crave a rustic bowl of carbonara or a delicate, hand-cut tajarin. We have prioritized restaurants that demonstrate consistency, quality of ingredients, and a distinct sense of place.
While Manhattan often dominates the conversation, Brooklyn and the outer boroughs are home to some of the most authentic and exciting kitchens in the country. This list balances the legendary stalwarts with the neighborhood gems that locals fiercely protect.
Understanding the landscape of Italian-American cuisine is essential to appreciating this list. The “red sauce joint” is an American institution, born from Southern Italian immigration, offering generous portions of parmigiana and baked ziti.
In contrast, the last two decades have seen a surge in regional Italian cooking, focusing on the specific traditions of areas like Emilia-Romagna, Campania, and Piedmont. We have included both styles because both are vital to the city’s culinary identity.
When evaluating these restaurants, we considered more than just the taste of the pasta. The quality of the bread and olive oil, the knowledge of the sommelier, the warmth of the service, and the overall atmosphere contribute to a dining experience.
A great Italian meal is about hospitality—the feeling that you are being welcomed into someone’s home. We looked for places that make you want to linger over an espresso and a grappa long after the plates are cleared.
Accessibility and value also played a role in our curation. While New York is home to some of the most expensive tasting menus in the world, Italian food is, at its heart, a cuisine of the people. We have included options for various budgets, from a casual lunch spot perfect for a quick bowl of pasta to a special-occasion destination worthy of a milestone celebration.
Great food should be available to everyone, and these restaurants reflect that philosophy. Below is our curated selection of the twelve best Italian restaurants currently operating in New York City.
Whether you are a lifelong New Yorker or a first-time visitor, these dining rooms represent the pinnacle of what the city has to offer in terms of flavor, tradition, and innovation.
Osteria Nonnino
| Address | 637 Hudson St, New York, NY 10014 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Tuesday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Wednesday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Thursday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM Friday: 4:00 – 11:00 PM Saturday: 12:00 – 11:00 PM Sunday: 12:00 – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (212) 625-3333 |
A friend of mine, who is a restauranteur recommended Osteria Nonnino, and it absolutely lived up to the hype. We were visiting from Colorado, and my husband is a huge Cacio e Pepe fan, so the tableside preparation was a must. The entire experience felt like we had stepped into Italy.
I ordered the Bolognese, and it was incredible. We also shared the carpaccio and Caprese salad, both of which were fresh and delicious. For dessert, we couldn’t resist the tableside tiramisu, along with the cheesecake and an espresso martini, which were the perfect ending to the meal.
A special thank you to our server, Luca, who made the experience even better with his outstanding service. If you’re looking for authentic Italian food and a memorable dining experience, I highly recommend Osteria Nonnino.
Came here with my wife and daughter. We had outdoor seating on a beautiful day. They were able to accommodate us 30 min earlier than our reservation time. They also had a high chair for us to use! The pasta dishes we got were delicious and service was great. A good italian spot to visit and worth a trip!
Had an amazing dinner date here!
We started off with some amazing wine selection they have here. Then had their calamari and my absolutely favorite was the cacio pepe prepared on the cheese wheel. One of the specials was chicken parm which we loved too. To top it all up, we had tableside served tiramisu. Highly recommend making reservations because this spot is popular and gets full fast!
The service and vibes are amazing. Looking forward to coming to visit again soon!
Highly recommend and will definitely be back!! All of the food was chef's kiss! Al, our server was wonderful - friendly, knowledgeable and attentive.
I ordered the orecchiette con bufala and my goodness it was to die for. My friends had the cacio e pepe (made tableside), gnocchi al pesto, rigatoni di nonnino, and one of the pasta specials (fettuccine with lemon). You can't go wrong with any of their pasta options!
Had a wonderful time with the wife Wednesday night.
Service was perfect, attentive but not overbearing. We had Luca for our server and when we come back, I’ll be asking for him. He was fantastic.
Food came out flawless, the pasta was cooked al dente. No complaints. We grabbed tiramisu for desert, made table side, and were very pleased with how it turned out. Unique, but prepared very well.
Atmosphere was lively, vibrant, but not too loud. A perfect vibe on a summer evening.
Looking forward to coming back and recommending to friends. Thank you!
Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC
| Address | 200 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Tuesday: 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Wednesday: 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Thursday: 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Friday: 11:30 AM – 12:00 AM Saturday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM Sunday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM |
| Phone | (212) 221-3800 |
Carmine's – Times Square is an excellent restaurant that offers delicious Italian food and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. From the moment I entered, the staff made me feel comfortable with their friendly and attentive service. The restaurant has a lively environment, making it a great place for families, friends, and special celebrations.
The food was the highlight of my visit. The pasta was fresh and flavorful, the pizza was perfectly cooked, and the desserts were absolutely delicious. The portions were very generous, making them ideal for sharing. Every dish was well prepared and served hot.
The restaurant was clean, beautifully decorated, and well organized despite being busy. The service was quick, and the staff were always ready to help with recommendations and ensure that everything was perfect.
Overall, I had a wonderful dining experience at Carmine's – Times Square. The combination of delicious food, excellent service, and a vibrant atmosphere made it a memorable visit. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone visiting New York City. It is definitely worth trying, and I would happily return again. I would give it 5 out of 5 stars.
A must visit restaurant when you are in Midtown. Huge family style portions, fast friendly service and a quality bartender! The wait staff doesn't miss a beat, they make sure your water is always full and that all your needs are met. I had a Manhattan with bourbon and it was perfect! They have a huge selection of spirits, beer and wine to meet anyone's taste. The food was excellent and there was so much left they box it up for you to take away for another fine meal! You won't regret stopping by.
This Italian restaurant is very popular, so reservations are definitely recommended. The seating is quite tight, but the staff are warm and attentive. The portions are surprisingly large, so be careful not to over-order—there’s plenty of food. The three of us shared one pasta and one breaded pork chop, and we could barely finish it.
Took my small family to this place. Really cool feel. There’s a reason why they don’t list the cost on the menu. The plates are oversized but you will be forced to buy for 3-4 people per serving. When you compare the price vs amount of food. Garlic bread with cheese 😆 $28. Pasta $47🤣🤣. Don’t just believe me, see the bill for yourself. Salad $32 🫨
Good taste. Food was good but the experience is ruined with the pricey bill. Took half if it home. What do you think? Is it going to taste the same after you microwave it? Nope.
When we visited New York, the one place we couldn't wait to return to since our last trip in 2022 was Carmine's—and it still completely blows us away! The lively, old-school atmosphere is unmatched, but the food and hospitality are the real stars. Cheiah and Patty gave us the absolute best menu suggestions and provided exceptional, friendly service that made our night. We ordered massive, family-style portions of the delicious fried zucchini, eggplant parmigiana, and a vegetarian-adapted penne alla vodka, ending the night with their spectacular strawberry shortcake. You get incredible value for the quantity of food, but it's the warm hospitality that keeps us coming back.
OLIO E PIÙ
| Address | 3 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10014 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM Thursday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM Friday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM Saturday: 10:00 AM – 12:00 AM Sunday: 10:00 AM – 12:00 AM |
| Phone | (212) 243-6546 |
We ordered two pastas and fritto primavera. Both pastas were solid. We had the carbonara and vongole. The vongole had a nice light kick to it, and the clams were wonderfully fresh and tender. They offered to grate fresh cheese over our dishes, which I agreed to expecting it just for the carbonara, but they added it to the vongole as well. A bit surprising, but no big deal at all.
The atmosphere is lovely, with the dining room seamlessly connected to the terrace, giving it a great open, airy feel. Our server, Turgut, was extremely friendly and genuinely attentive to making sure we enjoyed our meal. Another staff member, possibly the manager, also checked in on us periodically, making us feel well cared for throughout the evening. Overall, a great experience.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The pasta was absolutely delicious! We ordered the Carbonara and Vongole, and both dishes were fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The Carbonara was rich and creamy, while the Vongole had a wonderful garlic and seafood flavor.
The staff were all very friendly, and Turgut was especially kind and welcoming. He made us feel comfortable throughout the meal and provided excellent service.
Highly recommend this place if you’re looking for great pasta and warm hospitality. We would definitely come back!
Olio e Più has a great vibe and ambience, and the outdoor seating was especially nice. The staff was generally friendly as well.
We had the caponata, burrata, and meatballs. The caponata and burrata were tasty, but unfortunately, the meatballs were dry and rather flavorless.
The biggest issue was the service. I appreciate unobtrusive service, but our water glasses were never refilled, and we had to flag someone down for additional drinks. We also waited 20 minutes for some bread we had requested. And at $8 for a glass of Diet Coke, the pricing felt pretty steep.
Overall, the atmosphere and outdoor seating were enjoyable, but the food and service left something to be desired.
My husband and I dined at Olio for and early Sunday dinner. If you plan to come here during popular hours, definitely make a reservation as you may not be able to walk in and get a table. They have indoor and outdoor tables and I really appreciate the simple decor inside and has great lighting. Our server, Turgut, was incredibly friendly and attentive. I always always appreciate when people remember our names and/or ask our names and he did. He also let us know about the location in DC and a little bit of history about the restaurant which I loved. We ordered the lamb ragu pasta and the chicken piccata - highly recommend these items if you want a light meal to share! Turgut was so kind and thoughtful and gave us a complimentary dessert and we chose the olive oil cake. The entire staff is super friendly and I will definitely check out the DC location and will come back here again when I’m back visiting NYC. Ask for Turgut as your server when you come visit Olio! Bonus that’s is only a 4-mins walk to Washington square park so you can walk off your pasta. The outdoor tables will also be great when weather is nice out and people watch while you enjoy some aperitivo.
We dined at Olio e Più and the experience was overall quite pleasant.
The menu is well-curated, with inviting options. The staff is courteous and helpful.
The restaurant, very popular and with a lively atmosphere, reflects a predominantly tourist clientele. The tables are quite close together, and the noise level is high, which can impact the experience.
This is a detail that could be improved to enhance the quality of the food.
Overall, a good choice for those who want to enjoy Italian cuisine in a dynamic and lively setting.
Tony's Di Napoli
| Address | 147 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM Tuesday: 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Wednesday: 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Thursday: 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Friday: 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Saturday: 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Sunday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (212) 221-0100 |
Hands down, on July 16, 2026, we had one of the best dinners we’ve ever had. Delicious marinara sauce, family style (huge) portions, fresh innovative beet salad, fresh berry and lemon sorbet dessert, best cappuccino!!
Dinner came with entertainment too. Twice during our meal, a talented waiter broke out singing familiar Italian opera tunes on a handheld player and microphone. The clientele went wild and whipped their napkins in the air. I felt I was in the Sopranos or Godfather I (the wedding scene).
Tony’s Di Napoli is a great spot for a classic Italian meal, especially with a group. Located in the heart of Times Square —close to broadway theaters, it’s an easy & convenient place to meet. The family-style menu is perfect for sharing, with generous portions & delicious Italian favorites.
Friendly, attentive service & a lively atmosphere made for an excellent dining experience. We’d definitely return.
We came as a party of five with reservation before a Broadway show with 1 hr to eat. It was just about right!
We ordered Stuffed mushroom, Calamari fritti, Linguini w shrimp Luciano , Whole branzino, Chicken special.
The appetizer calamari was good. Branzino was amazing. Chicken and linguini was so so, probably wouldn’t get again.
Good spot for family, does get a bit rowdy and noisy.
Very nice New York Italian atmosphere! There was some excellent singing! The staff made us feel very special and took care of us the whole time. Portions are big, we shared three and ordered a great red wine. We did not finish them so we were able to take them away! Great quality! Visited in November 2025
Here’s an updated version that incorporates those additional details while keeping it natural and appropriate for a Google review:
I came to Tony’s Di Napoli because of the incredible reviews, and I have to admit I wondered if they were a little overhyped. They weren’t. This restaurant exceeded every expectation.
Even on a packed evening, I was dining solo and was able to grab a seat at the bar, which turned out to be the perfect place to experience the energy of the restaurant. Tony’s has been a New York institution for decades, and it’s easy to see why. The place was absolutely buzzing with locals, theatergoers, families, and visitors, creating one of those classic New York dining experiences you hope to find.
The food was outstanding. The mussels were among the best I’ve ever had, and the broth was so incredible I ordered an extra basket of their fantastic bread just to soak up every last drop. The Linguine with White Clam Sauce was equally impressive—I honestly don’t think I’ve ever been served so many fresh clams with a pasta dish.
One thing that really stood out was the value. Considering the quality of the food, the generous portions, and the location just steps from Times Square, the prices were surprisingly reasonable. You truly get a lot for your money.
The cocktails were excellent. The sangria was refreshing, but the Prickly Pear cocktail absolutely stole the show. I couldn’t leave without dessert and ordered the Affogato. Without exaggeration, it was the best affogato I have ever had anywhere in the world. It was the perfect ending to an exceptional meal.
Looking around the dining room, it was obvious why so many dishes have loyal followings. The Veal Parmesan, Sausage & Peppers, and Rigatoni alla Vodka were flying out of the kitchen and looked incredible. It’s easy to see why Tony’s is famous for its generous family-style Italian meals and why so many groups return time and time again.
What impressed me most, though, was the staff. The bartender never stopped moving, yet somehow remained friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming throughout the evening. That level of hospitality is becoming rare, and it made an already fantastic meal even better.
If you’re visiting Times Square and want an authentic, lively Italian restaurant that delivers on both atmosphere and outstanding food, Tony’s Di Napoli is an easy recommendation. Just be prepared—it’s extremely popular. Make a reservation if you can, or, if you’re dining solo like I was, the bar is a fantastic option.
I know one thing for certain: I’ll be back again and again. This is one of those restaurants that reminds you why New York City is one of the great food destinations in the world. Five stars.
Osteria La Baia
| Address | 129 W 52nd St, New York, NY 10019 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 8:00 – 11:00 AM, 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Tuesday: 8:00 – 11:00 AM, 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Wednesday: 8:00 – 11:00 AM, 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Thursday: 8:00 – 11:00 AM, 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM Friday: 8:00 – 11:00 AM, 11:30 AM – 12:00 AM Saturday: 11:30 AM – 12:00 AM Sunday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (917) 671-9898 |
The food was incredible. The level of service is outstanding! The staff made us feel welcome like we were having dinner at home. I loved the gnocchi pasta dish the most. We ordered a ton. Highly recommend! Blerta and Marco were awesome! They made our experience even better than just the delicious food.
We were here to celebrate a friend’s birthday, and everything about the experience was wonderful. The ambiance was warm, stylish, and perfect for a special occasion.
We started with the burrata and eggplant parmigiana, and both were absolutely delicious. For the main course, we ordered the cacio e pepe and the pasta alla vodka, and both dishes were rich, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. We ended the meal with the tiramisu, which was the perfect.
This place offers a great combination of delicious food, a beautiful ambiance, and a lively yet relaxed atmosphere.
First time back in NYC after 10 years and this is the first sit down restaurant I had here since my last time here. I had high expectations, and this restaurant solidified that NYC is still the hub for great food. Omer was attentive and so kind. Food was a 4.5/5 lobster fettuccine amazing. Squid ink pasta salted a little too much. Beet salad and fritto misto great. Arancini good. Drinks, must order. Ambiance perfect. Wait stag was also on top of everything. Never let our glasses go empty and plates cleared immediately. Overall pls come here if you’re looking for a nice sit down pasta dinner!
Osteria La Baia is an excellent choice if you’re looking for a nicer dinner late night! Pietro was so friendly and attentive, as was everyone else we interacted with. The pappardelle bolognese was incredible as was the gnocchi caprese. The crème brûlée was AMAZING and the drinks including pecan espresso martini were excellent.
Overall a really wonderful experience, and honestly not too expensive all things considered for a nicer Italian spot in midtown. Highly recommend, and special kudos again to Pietro and team for making our night particularly special. 🙂
My server Omer was, if I can put it in words, over the top better then nice. It was very pleasant and a very beautiful restaurant. We didn’t like the table we were going to be put at by the hostess but a lovely man from management put me and my partner to a much better table where we didn’t feel crammed. The food was lovely, the eggplant parm was to die for. I couldn’t embarrassingly stop licking the plate. LOL! The cocktails were perfect I had the Hollywood drink was refreshing annd perfect, not too strong. Over all I can’t wait to be back here again.
Scarpetta
| Address | 88 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:30 AM – 2:30 PM, 5:00 – 9:00 PM Tuesday: 11:30 AM – 2:30 PM, 5:00 – 9:30 PM Wednesday: 11:30 AM – 2:30 PM, 5:00 – 9:30 PM Thursday: 11:30 AM – 2:30 PM, 5:00 – 9:30 PM Friday: 11:30 AM – 2:30 PM, 5:00 – 10:00 PM Saturday: 5:00 – 10:00 PM Sunday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM |
| Phone | (212) 691-0555 |
From the moment I walked through the doors, I knew I was in for an exceptional evening. I was greeted by a lovely group of hostesses who were incredibly welcoming. As it turned out, I got my times crossed up—I thought our reservation was at 5:00 PM, but it was actually 6:30 PM. (Getting old sucks, lol!) Instead of making me feel awkward about being so early, they told me to make myself at home and enjoy the bar.That mistake turned out to be a blessing because I met Daniel and Christian. These bartenders are absolute masters of their craft. They served me hands down the best Negroni I have ever tasted in my life—so good that I had to order a few more throughout the evening!The restaurant itself is a visual masterpiece—absolutely beautiful, aesthetically sophisticated, and gorgeous.Once my buddies arrived, we were seated and taken care of by David and Martin, alongside Marcel the Sommelier. This team is world-class. Every single recommendation they made was spot on, the ingredients were fresh and top-notch, and the food was spectacular. I truly couldn’t have asked for more.Do yourself a favor and check this place out for your next special occasion. It is not cheap by a long shot, but it is absolutely worth every penny for an incredible, elite dining experience. I already can’t wait to bring my wife back to try the rest of the menu!
We went to Scarpetta tonight to celebrate my wife's 40th birthday. I booked the reservation in advance and simply stated that it was her birthday and if they could do anything to make her feel special that would be lovely. From the moment we arrived we were treated with an amazing level of detailed attention that felt like we were special. Our waters were filled constantly, our questions were answered immediately and with care, and every need was attended to like we were family despite it being a busy dinner rush. The food became almost an afterthought which is criminal because it was beyond spectacular in every sense of the word. My picky wife ate out of her comfort zone the offerings were so good! The sommelier gave a wonderful wine recommendation, and the staff even made a beautiful impromptu dessert for her that was allergy specific. I called the manager over just to say thank you for such a special evening. Could not recommend enough
Husband & I went here for Valentine's Day for their Prefix menu, & OMG!! We have told everyone to take their spouses there for the last month. Great experience from start to finish - cocktails were fabulous, ambiance was romantic, & our server was attentive & honest in his recommendations. I will say, after a few drinks, the bathroom is a mission - but still beautiful (as a bathroom can be?) & clean! This is where your next romantic dinner should be!
We went for our anniversary. I called ahead and also filled out the questionnaire with our reservation letting them know it was our anniversary along with dietary restrictions. Started rough out the gate but they very quickly recovered and more from a service standpoint. Drinks were great and the wine list was extensive. The chef added a couple items on the house along the night. The food was good for sure, but I can’t say it was worth the price. The atmosphere wasn’t my favorite either, again not bad but just not the romantic vibe we were expecting. Highlight was the service for sure. I’m glad we went but I think I’d try somewhere else if I could do it again.
The food was very good but the front area only for lunch looks cheap with fake plants. The inner room looks better so for me as a person who came for the atmosphere was a bit disappointing. If just the the food it was perfect.
La Lanterna di Vittorio
| Address | 129 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 10:00 AM – 1:00 AM Tuesday: 10:00 AM – 1:00 AM Wednesday: 10:00 AM – 1:00 AM Thursday: 10:00 AM – 1:00 AM Friday: 10:00 AM – 2:00 AM Saturday: 10:00 AM – 2:00 AM Sunday: 10:00 AM – 1:00 AM |
| Phone | (917) 639-3236 |
La Lanterna di Vittorio was the perfect place for a relaxed and enjoyable lunch. From the moment we arrived, everything was simple, efficient, and welcoming, creating exactly the kind of atmosphere you hope to find in a great neighborhood Italian restaurant.
The food was excellent. Every dish was fresh, flavorful, and prepared with care, showcasing authentic Italian cuisine without trying to overcomplicate it. The quality of the ingredients really stood out, and each bite reflected the restaurant’s commitment to traditional flavors.
One of the highlights was the service. It was fast, friendly, and efficient, allowing us to enjoy our meal without unnecessary waiting or excessive formality. Everything flowed naturally, making for a very pleasant dining experience.
A special recommendation goes to the bruschetta—it was absolutely delicious and a perfect way to start the meal. Fresh, beautifully balanced, and full of flavor, it’s definitely something you shouldn’t miss when visiting.
Overall, La Lanterna di Vittorio offers exactly what a great Italian restaurant should: delicious food, prompt and attentive service, a warm atmosphere, and an experience that feels genuine rather than overly complicated. I would happily return and highly recommend it to anyone looking for an excellent lunch in New York.
Large menu, delicious pizza, pasta, cheese, etc. Ordered a margarita which was average. Liked the tiramisu. Service was attentive, I think there was a bit of a language barrier. The lasagna is so rich and tasty. We were seated in the back patio which was really cute and a nice setting for a work dinner or really any occasion.
La Lanterna di Vittorio was an amazing choice for a Valentine’s Day dinner, and I was highly impressed from the moment we walked in all the way through dessert. The atmosphere is incredibly charming and intimate, especially with the cozy, unique layout that makes it feel like a hidden gem in the West Village. It’s definitely on the smaller side, which adds to the experience, but I highly recommend making reservations ahead of time because it fills up quickly—especially on special occasions.
The food was outstanding. You absolutely have to get the lasagna—it was one of the highlights of the night. The portions were very filling, and the flavors were rich, authentic, and clearly made with care. Everything tasted fresh and homemade, and there were so many great options on the menu that it was tough to choose.
The tiramisu dessert was also highly recommended by the staff, and they were 100% right. It was the perfect way to end the meal—light, flavorful, and easily one of the better tiramisus I’ve had.
The staff was fantastic as well—friendly, attentive, and made the whole experience feel special without being overbearing. Overall, this place exceeded expectations in every way. I would absolutely recommend it for a date night or special occasion and would gladly come back again.
This place is GORGEOUS! Such a beautiful and cozy spot - perfect for date night, solo dining or with just a couple of people. Went recently with a friend and we fell IN LOVE with the place. Unfortunately the Garden sitting area in the back was packed that night (the main floor dining area on the other hand was not packed). We did sit at a corner spot which gave us a glimpse into the garden area. I literally felt like I was in some Italian restaurant. Loved the overall ambience.
The food was good...I docked it one star because although we ordered one of their most popular items (the classic lasagna-pictured) we noticed that the lasagna was more cheese than pasta making it excessively greasy. Literally tasted like we were eating baked cheese with meat. Drinks on the other hand were delicious.
(Nov 6, 2025)
I was introduced to this restaurant when I went here with my friends who were looking for a "good dinner" in their NYC visit. I am glad I didn't alter their plan with a different suggestion of my own. This restaurant has cozy interiors, dim-lit décor, friendly and helpful waiters, delicious hot cheesy food.
My friend and I shared a Pesto-based minestrone soup---mild, watery, not salty, had nice starchy vegetables.
I would've had the sweet potato soup if it didn't have chicken stock, I wish they keep a vegan version of it.
Then, we had the vegetarian 'flight lasagna', a combo of 4 cups of different lasagna. They also had non-vegetarian variants to it, and I guess it's a very popular item as almost all tables had the `flight lasagna'.
We enjoyed all the four flavours.
Lasagna 1 -- Four cheese -- Couldn't tell apart the cheeses, all of it was white and fatty.
Lasagna 2 -- Mushroom -- The burn (brown char) on the top lasagna sheet or some added chilli-infused oil gave a spicy (காரம்) and tantalizing taste.
Lasagna 3 -- Arrabiatta -- It is spicy-hot (காரம்) more than it is tomato-tangy.
Lasagna 4 -- Pesto -- Good.
I took a bite out of the arrabiatta gluten-free pizza that another friend had ordered. The crust was not good, felt more like a biscuit (brick) than a bread.
The topping was very similar to the flavour of the corresponding lasagna that I had.
We spent about $30 per person + tips.
Osteria Barocca
| Address | 133 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Thursday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Friday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM Saturday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM Sunday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (212) 951-1323 |
Amazing experience! we started with the calamari which were prepared to perfection! Had a Pink Panther and Italian Margarita for cocktails. Mains were the Carrbonara and a modified Pesto dish then the staff surprised us by coming out with an amazing Tiramisu to sing us Happy Birthday! Finished off with Limoncello Martinis - don't sleep on the cocktails here - Definitely recommend and will be visiting here again!
Absolutely amazing experience! The food was fresh, authentic, and full of flavor. The pasta was perfectly cooked, the sauce tasted homemade, and every dish was beautifully presented. The service was warm, attentive, and made us feel truly welcome from the moment we arrived. The atmosphere was cozy, inviting, and perfect for a relaxing meal. From the appetizers to the dessert, everything exceeded our expectations. I highly recommend this restaurant and can’t wait to come back!
So glad we came across Osteria Barocca. From the moment we walked in their entire team including Ayman, Bayran, and made us feel welcome. It’s such a cozy beautiful decorated restuarnt right in little Italy. Our server was Bayran, he was very professional and attentive! We ordered a bottle of Pinot noir mozzarella sticks, and chicken parmigano. Everything was so delicious, right on point and can’t believe we just discovered them after coming to the city all these years! Keep up the amazing and not to mention fresh pasta made as your drink and enjoy your appetizers! We can’t wait to visit again soon!
We had a wonderful experience at Osteria Barocca! We came as a family of six, and everyone ordered something different. Every dish was absolutely delicious, the service was friendly, and the atmosphere was great. We’ll definitely come back the next time we’re in New York. Highly recommend!
The only reason this restaurant doesn’t get 5 stars is I don’t like being talked into a restaurant. HOWEVER I’m so glad I did. I have travelled the world and extensively in Italy, but this restaurant provided me with the best pasta I have ever eaten. Perfect texture, al dente and omg the best! So let the guys get you into this restaurant and enjoy the quality of food they provide. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Giulietta
| Address | 200 Park Ave, New York, NY 10166 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 7:00 AM – 9:30 PM Tuesday: 7:00 AM – 9:30 PM Wednesday: 7:00 AM – 9:30 PM Thursday: 7:00 AM – 9:30 PM Friday: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM Saturday: 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM Sunday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Phone | (212) 597-2424 |
The service was impeccable, and the food was absolutely delicious with very generous portions. The restaurant has such a beautiful Italian summer vibe and a lovely atmosphere. Definitely worth checking out!
I can’t wait to go back and try more items. the app and the entree were so good. the dessert missed the mark for us but that may have been because we didn’t really know what we were ordering lol It’s always busy during lunch time. Gorgeous venue.
Really nice spot for a casual meal. The restaurant has a warm, family-friendly atmosphere with bright, colorful decor that makes the space feel welcoming, especially for families with kids.
The food was good and the portions were just right for individual meals. Service was friendly, and everything came out on time.
Nothing in particular really stood out, but overall everything was solid and we had a pleasant experience. It’s a good place if you’re looking for a comfortable restaurant with a nice atmosphere.
Firstly, this Giulietta is in no way related to the italian one on College St (Toronto) by Chef Bob Rossi. I spoke to the servers to confirm it!
That said, the food here is really delicious, prices are affordable, portion is fair and more importantly, the decoration pops and is very chic, especially for the gram. My personal thoughts on food that was ordered:
- Fritto Misto: can’t go wrong with fried seafood things! Yum!
- Truffle pizza: so delicious, and rich! The undercarriage was also well cooked.
- Garganello: sooooooo good, the pasta was cooked al dente, the arugula pesto was fresh and well seasoned. I don’t know, it was really bomb dot com.
- Torts caprese: not too sweet, light, a pretty good wrap up to the whole meal!
The restaurant just opened for a month or so when this review was written. Walked in on a Friday night — no problem. They have sooo much seating space so don’t fret if you didn’t make any reservations. Definitely will be back to try other menu items, and to enjoy the meal outdoors especially during patio szn! 🙂
Aug 2026 update: Came by here again and had lobster pasta and brussel sprouts, shared between two persons. Left the establishment really full but delighted at how delicious the food was! Will be back!
This restaurant was built for women! My favorite part was that my legs didn’t stick To the booth when I stood up, Not to mention every bit of food and service was top notch. I honestly can say this is a new top favorite.
Check out was an absolute breeze!
Zia Maria Little Italy
| Address | 138 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Thursday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Friday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM Saturday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM Sunday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (646) 590-7873 |
We were seated immediately. Our food was amazing! My daughter and I shared. The portions are generous. Our server never came back after he took our order. I loved being on the street with the fun lights. I would highly recommend the food & atmosphere, but hope for a more attentive server.
Came here for a date night with my hubby! And it was definitely worth it. The calamari appetizer is a must get! One of the best Caesar salads I’ve had— very flavorful & cheesy! We ordered chicken parmigiana & linguini vongole. Both were delicious & not too heavy. The staff was very positive, welcoming, and made our experience great! I highly recommend this spot & will definitely be back!
Nice owner and service. If you are Gluten Free the pasta was so so.
We got the recommended pasta that was $65 with the cheese bowl thing.. and we ordered the Alfredo (most similar on the menu).
Didn’t taste much of a difference to be honest.
Not worth $65 for a plate.
We are in NYC for the Tall Ships and decided to venture into Little Italy for lunch and chose Zia Maria at the insistence of Mario. We watched the World Cup match there Between Argentina and Egypt, the atmosphere was Electric! The service was absolutely fantastic and the food was sensational! My wife had the gluten free pizza which was the best she ever had and I had the fresh pasta special of the day made in the cheese wheel which I watched them make it and that experience alone was priceless! Thank you Verano for making the wonderful pasta dish and Mario for attracting us in! Thank you Zia Maria for an amazing lunch experience and making us feel like family! Can’t wait to comeback! Cheers!
There are a lot of great restaurants in NYC's Little Italy neighborhood but none better than Zia Maria. From the moment we showed up and stated we had reservations, we knew this was a special place. Treated like family by host and server from seating to discussion of specials, the cheese wheel pasta made tableside was every bit the event we expected it to be and the end result was worth every bite we ate and every dollar spent, the dish is large enough to be shared by two but still leaving room for their tiramisu and italian cheesecake. Top notch drinks, food and service equals a solid 5 stars.
La Pecora Bianca NoMad
| Address | 1133 Broadway, New York, NY 10010 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM Tuesday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM Wednesday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM Thursday: 11:30 AM – 10:30 PM Friday: 11:30 AM – 10:30 PM Saturday: 10:00 AM – 4:00 PM, 5:00 – 10:30 PM Sunday: 10:00 AM – 4:00 PM, 5:00 – 9:30 PM |
| Phone | (212) 498-9696 |
What an amazing dining experience!
The steak was absolutely outstanding — without a doubt one of the best steaks I have ever had in my life. It was perfectly cooked, flavorful, and unforgettable. Everything else we ordered was equally delicious and beautifully prepared.
A special thank you to the bartender, who was incredibly attentive, professional, and friendly throughout our visit. His excellent service made the entire experience even more enjoyable.
The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, and every detail reflected great care and hospitality. We will definitely be back and highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for exceptional food and service in New York.
We initially assumed La Pecora Bianca might be one of those restaurants that caters mainly to tourists because of its location and popularity. We couldn’t have been more wrong.
What started as a convenient stop turned into a good surprise of our trip. The food was consistently good, fresh, flavorful, and well executed. Every dish we tried was spot on.
The service was equally enjoyable—friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming, creating a relaxed atmosphere that made us want to stay longer.
The restaurant strikes a great balance between quality and accessibility, making it the kind of place that works whether you’re looking for a casual lunch, a relaxed dinner, or simply a good meal while exploring the city.
A very pleasant surprise and definitely somewhere we’ll happily stop again the next time we’re passing through NoMad.
Really delicious handmade pasta in Nomad area. I came here for my Birthday. I started with the Whipped Ricotta with truffle honey and it's very earthy and comes with really good crispy bread which i believe is from Balthazar Bakery. They brought extra over too. For main I got the Campanelle pasta with a creamy lemony sauce and plump shrimp that comes out covered with Parmesan cheese. Delicious. It's very slightly al dente . But not too much so it didn't bother me .I sat inside and there was air conditioning inside . This is a lively place with an open kitchen in the back. I was here at 5.15 on a Tuesday and it was filling up by the time I left. But definitely get some pasta if you come here. The sauce was so good .
I’ve eaten here a few times, and while the meals have generally been average and decent, today was a major disappointment.
I was walking by, drawn in by the outdoor seating and decided to stop for a quick pasta. Unfortunately, that turned out to be a mistake. I ordered the cacio e pepe, which was incredibly oily. The more I ate, the worse it became. I didn’t send it back because I felt uncomfortable with how that might be received by the kitchen, and ultimately finished it simply because I was hungry.
The level of care with the takeout order was equally disappointing. I asked for my ricotta and toast to be packed to go, and it was carelessly smashed together in the same container. It seems like basic common sense that the cheese and bread should be packed separately—or at the very least partitioned—to prevent the bread from becoming soggy. For a restaurant in this price range, that lack of attention to detail is hard to understand, particularly when the patio was not full and there were plenty of servers available. I also was not asked if I wanted anything else or if I wanted a refill of wine when the glass was near empty.
I still left a 20% tip, but spending nearly $100 for an experience this poor was deeply frustrating. I won’t ever be returning, but I hope management takes this feedback and uses it to improve the experience for current and future diners.
Food is delicious! We've been here twice and both times the food was perfect. The cauliflower appetizer is absolutely amazing. The service was outstanding. We did have a reservation, the place is always busy. I definitely recommend making a reservation. They have great outdoor seating when weather permits.
AMALFI Rooftop by Birreria
| Address | 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Thursday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Friday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Sunday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (212) 229-2560 |
The interior design was absolutely beautiful, every little detail had Amalfi Coast vibes and there were lemons everywhere 🍋.My friend tried the limoncello and loved it, and we also ordered the watermelon cello which was so refreshing. I got the Tagliolino al Limone and it was fresh, buttery, lemony and perfectly balanced. One of my friends got the seafood pasta and another got a gnocchi style pasta, everything tasted amazing. Honestly the focaccia might have been the best thing on the table, warm, soft, crispy outside with olive oil and rosemary. And the tiramisu at the end was incredible. Yes it is a bit pricey, but the quality, atmosphere and overall experience absolutely make it worth it.
Beautiful decor, only complaint was that it was warm. Service impeccable. Recognized my birthday without even saying anything because I wore a small bday pin.
Amalfi Pop-Up is worth checking out. The food was really good overall—especially the calamari, which tasted fresh and perfectly cooked. The focaccia bread was also a standout (simple, but done really well).
Drinks were solid too, with a good mix of cocktails and wines to choose from. The only downside is that the portions are a little on the smaller side for the price.
The space is beautifully decorated, with lemons and greenery covering the ceiling that gives it a fun, Amalfi Coast vibe.
Overall, a really nice spot with quality food and a nice vibe—just don’t expect huge portions.
I really loved the food and the drinks, but it was extremely hot inside. I was sweating the entire time, and I’m not usually someone who sweats easily. Unfortunately, the temperature made it uncomfortable to stay, and I just wanted to finish my meal and leave. The food and drinks were great, but the atmosphere would have been much more enjoyable if it had been cooler.
3.5 / 5.0 - The Amalfi Rooftop is beautifully decorated year-round, changing per season. We came for lunch today and because it was just before noon on a weekday, it wasn’t very busy.
The roof was open and most tables were directly under the sun. We chose one of the very few tables which was in the shade, although it was later under the sun and started getting hot.
I’ve had several pasta dishes here over the years, but today’s lunch was a disappointment. I ordered the Italian Lunch (starting at $26), with Insalata di Agrumi for appetizer and Spaghetti Chitarra alla Nerano for main.
The citrus salad was fine but the spaghetti, which is supposed to come with fried zucchini, had 3 super thinly sliced of zucchini and that was it. I was expecting it to have thicker and at the least, more slices. When I first saw it, I thought there would be more inside, but there was none. The pasta and cheese were good, but I would not recommend ordering this dish unless that’s all you want.
Tips for Choosing the Perfect Italian Restaurant in NYC
Selecting a restaurant in a city with thousands of options can be daunting, but a little strategy goes a long way. The best choice often depends on your specific mood, budget, and location. Here are some expert tips to help you navigate the city’s Italian dining scene like a local, ensuring you get the most out of your culinary adventure.
1). Know Your Regional Preferences
Italian cuisine is not a monolith; it varies drastically from north to south. Northern Italian food often features butter, risotto, and beef, while Southern Italian cooking leans on olive oil, tomatoes, and seafood.
If you are looking for a specific dish, research whether the restaurant specializes in that region. A place known for Sicilian seafood will likely serve a better pasta con le sarde than a Tuscan steakhouse.
2). Book Ahead, Especially for Legends
The most famous names on this list often book out weeks, sometimes months, in advance. If you have your heart set on a specific institution, do not leave your reservation to chance.
Set a reminder for when their reservation books open, typically at midnight or 9 AM. For last-minute planners, eating at the bar is often a viable and enjoyable alternative that requires no reservation.
3). Embrace the Lunch Menu
Dining at a high-end Italian restaurant for lunch is the best-kept secret in New York City. You can often experience the same handmade pasta and refined service at a fraction of the dinner price.
Lunch menus frequently feature prix-fixe deals that offer exceptional value. It is the perfect way to sample a top-tier kitchen without the top-tier dinner bill.
4). Ask About the Off-Menu Specials
In many authentic Italian restaurants, the true magic lies in what is not printed on the menu. Servers will often recite a list of daily specials based on what the chef found at the market that morning.
Listen carefully to these offerings, as they usually feature the freshest seasonal ingredients. Do not be afraid to ask for the price of a special before ordering to avoid surprises on the bill.
5). Don’t Skip the Antipasti and Dolci
A common mistake is filling up on bread and focusing solely on the secondi (main course). The appetizers and desserts are often where Italian chefs showcase their creativity and technique.
Ordering a vegetable antipasti or a fresh burrata can be the highlight of the meal. Similarly, always save room for a traditional tiramisu or a scoop of house-made gelato; skipping dessert in a great Italian restaurant is a culinary sin.
The beauty of New York’s Italian dining scene lies in its diversity and depth. From the crackle of a wood-fired oven in a bustling pizzeria to the quiet elegance of a Michelin-starred dining room, there is a perfect plate of pasta waiting for every type of diner.
Exploring these restaurants is not just about eating; it is about experiencing the history, passion, and culture that Italian immigrants have woven into the fabric of New York City. As trends come and go, these establishments remain anchored by a respect for quality ingredients and time-honored techniques.
We encourage you to use this guide as a starting point for your own exploration. Venture into new neighborhoods, try a dish you have never heard of, and discover your own personal favorite among the thousands of incredible Italian kitchens this city has to offer.
