Finding the perfect place to stay in New York City can transform a simple visit into an unforgettable experience, especially when you want to be in the heart of Manhattan’s spiritual and architectural grandeur. St. Patrick’s Cathedral, a neo-Gothic masterpiece, sits as a beacon of tranquility amidst the bustling energy of Fifth Avenue. Whether you are visiting for a religious service, admiring the stunning stained-glass windows, or using the cathedral as a jumping-off point for Midtown exploration, the location is unrivaled.
Choosing accommodation near this landmark places you steps away from Rockefeller Center, the luxury shopping of Fifth Avenue, and the bright lights of Times Square. However, the sheer volume of hotels in Midtown can be overwhelming, ranging from opulent five-star establishments to stylish boutique hideaways. The right hotel should offer a sanctuary from the city’s relentless pace while keeping you connected to the landmarks you came to see.
This curated guide focuses on properties that offer exceptional quality, distinct character, and prime walkability to St. Patrick’s Cathedral. We have analyzed guest reviews, amenities, and architectural significance to ensure you find a stay that matches your travel style and budget. From historic icons that have hosted presidents to modern skyscrapers with sweeping skyline views, there is a perfect match for every traveler.
Whether your priority is a world-class spa, a Michelin-starred restaurant, or simply a plush bed after a long day of walking, the surrounding blocks offer everything. Being centrally located means you can easily pop back to your room to drop off shopping bags or rest your feet before an evening show. The convenience of staying near this landmark cannot be overstated for maximizing your New York itinerary.
In this list, we break down the top ten hotels that consistently deliver excellence in hospitality, location, and comfort. We have considered the nuances of each property, from the opulence of their lobbies to the quality of their room service. Read on to discover which hotel aligns best with your vision of a perfect Manhattan getaway.
Here are the 10 best hotels near St. Patrick’s Cathedral, each offering a unique gateway to the heart of New York City.
Lotte New York Palace
| Address | 455 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10022 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | — |
| Phone | (212) 888-7000 |
I do not know how this hotel is this well rated. The service, especially at the checkin counter is horrible. At Checkin and Checkout, the agent addressed us in the most rude way before even saying hello. They immediately said "wait, wait, wait" - not "Hello, I will be right with you!". immediately the impression is you are not a valued customer - they have more important things to do.
I am nor sure you can tell from the photo but the beds were very soft, warn out, and the mattresses were add depressed. The most uncomfortable bed I have experienced at a "high end" hotel.
The cleaning staff were very pleasant, but the room service and staff for the meeting rooms service of food, were extremely abrupt and not at all pleasant when they addressed us.
I had Breakfast at the restaurant in the hotel and again for the price point of the meal, I would expect first class service. Food was put in front of you, orders were taken with no pleasantries or consideration of asking the customer if they were happy/ satisfied. The coffee was bitter - as it if stayed on a plate/ warmer too long. Food quality was good though but better be for thr price you pay.
You may stay hear for location but there are many better hotels I have stayed at in the mId-town area! Avoid this hotel.
**Extremely Disappointing — Not Worth the Price**
I was extremely disappointed with my stay at Lotte New York Palace. For a hotel charging these kinds of rates, I expected a much higher level of quality, comfort, and basic amenities.
The rooms are very outdated, with old carpeting that had an unpleasant smell. The overall condition of the room felt more like an older, tired hotel than a luxury property. I specifically requested two queen beds, but the beds we received were full-size and noticeably smaller than expected.
What was most disappointing was the lack of basic in room amenities. There was no coffee or tea and no coffee maker in the room. In a hotel at this price point, I consider having the ability to make a cup of coffee in the morning to be a very basic expectation.
But what was truly unbelievable was being told that it would cost approximately $36–$38 simply to have a coffee maker brought to the room so we could make our own coffee. Charging nearly $40 for something that should be standard in a hotel of this caliber is simply unreasonable.
There were also no toiletries and conveniences compared with what I would expect from a luxury hotel
The bottom line is that the hotel is charging luxury prices and providing probably a motel 6 experience. The rooms are dated, the carpeting smells, the beds were smaller than expected, and basic amenities are either missing or come with surprisingly high additional charges.
The location may be excellent, but that alone does not justify the price. For what this hotel charges, there are many better choices in New York. I would not stay here again.
We chose to stay at Lotte New York Palace for my 21st birthday back in November ‘24 for 3 nights & our stay was nothing short of exceptional! From the gorgeous room upon arrival, huge plush bedding & a view of the city it was perfect for our first time in New York. Service was immaculate & the front of house team were so friendly & such a laugh every morning, they gave us recommendations & helped grab taxis throughout our stay. We explored the hotel & every corner was oozing with charm in all the details. I would 100% recommend the Palace for its renowned location steps away from New York’s most iconic items & its impeccable service! 🎀
Had a fantastic stay at Lotte New York Palace! The location is hard to beat, putting you right in the heart of New York City and within walking distance of so many attractions. The staff was outstanding from check-in to check-out and genuinely made us feel welcome throughout our stay. The spa amenities were a great bonus, with both a sauna and steam room available to enjoy after a busy day in the city. The gym is well-equipped and more than adequate for keeping up with workouts while traveling. The hotel has a luxurious feel, excellent service, and a great overall atmosphere. I would absolutely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone visiting New York.
Very nice hotel. Rooms were a bit outdated, but well kept. We had a great view of the midtown skyline and the location (close to grand central and central park and broadway) could not be beat. We look forward to staying here again in the future.
The Jewel Hotel, New York
| Address | 11 W 51st St, New York, NY 10019 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | — |
| Phone | (212) 863-0550 |
Extremely clean and comfortable hotel with a perfect location. Highly recommended! It is close to New York’s main tourist attractions, with easy access to the subway and Times Square.
I made my reservation through Booking, and at first an amount was charged/held on my card, but it was later refunded and everything went smoothly.
I had a great experience. Excellent value for money, highly recommended, and I will definitely stay there again.
From the moment I arrived at The Jewel NYC, I was genuinely impressed. The staff is the perfect combination of professional, friendly, and accommodating; they go above and beyond to make every guest feel welcome and ensure that every request is handled promptly and with genuine care.
One of the standout aspects of my stay was the incredible attention to cleanliness. Every part of the hotel, from the lobby and common areas to the hallways and guest rooms, was impeccably maintained. It's clear that the team takes tremendous pride in creating a spotless, comfortable environment, and that attention to detail did not go unnoticed.
What truly sets this hotel apart is how effortlessly it makes you feel at home. The thoughtfully provided amenities, comfortable accommodations, and inviting atmosphere create the perfect balance of convenience and relaxation. Whether you're visiting New York for business or leisure, everything you need is right at your fingertips, making your stay both stress-free and enjoyable.
The Jewel NYC exceeded my expectations in every way. Exceptional service, immaculate cleanliness, and a welcoming environment made for an outstanding experience. I wouldn't hesitate to stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a boutique hotel in the heart of Midtown Manhattan.
Location, location, location!
But the added bonus was how comfortable the rooms are (the most comfortable hotel bed I've ever slept in. Not too hard, not too soft. Goldilocks would say it's just right!). They're small rooms, but have everything you need and it's so quiet! Front desk staff is very welcoming, friendly, helpful. Easy check in, easy check out!
Had a great time at The Jewel, the location is exceptional.
I had an issue with my TV and in less than 30 minutes an engineer came by and fixed everything!
Staff is always friendly when you go in and out of the lobby and the amenities in my room were great, especially the mini fridge in my room and the ice machine on the fifth floor.
First choice for when I come back to NYC for sure!
I loved my time here. The staff is amazing and my group truly enjoyed our experience. They delivered us plates and utensils to our room when we had leftovers from one of our outings. We felt very attended to and they even scheduled a taxi back to the airport for us when our vacation was reaching the end.
Very relaxing and nice rooms, they have a water station and it was a life saver for us since our schedule was so busy it helped us stay hydrated, overall lovely!
It’s a wonderful location being so close to the Rockefeller center, it saved us from having to get an Uber a lot of the time.
Omni Berkshire Place
| Address | 21 E 52nd St, New York, NY 10022 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | — |
| Phone | (212) 753-5800 |
One of the best mid range hotels in New York. It’s always our first choice when booking a room in the city. You can’t beat the location. The rooms are a bit out dated in style, but they are immaculately kept. Good size rooms, comfortable beds and spacious bathrooms. The staff are wonderful…professional and friendly. I’m sorry I don’t have the names of people at the front desk because I’d like to commend them personally. The woman who took care of our room, Leticia Tineo, did a a wonderful job. Thanks to all for contributing to a terrific stay.
Every time we come into the city we choose The Omni Hotel, the staff from the front door to the room are amazing, polite, courteous, professional and personable. The rooms are clean, quiet, and very comfortable. Had a very intoxicated individual banging on the wrong door at 4:30am, called the front desk to handle it after my little verbal warning to him did not work, and they took care of it within minutes.
We will be back again for sure!
If you’re a quant, a Tibetan monk or a ghost, you’ll enjoy this hotel. The mountain-like cold chambers, the absence of warm beverages, the lack of blankets: everything is made to test your will, so that you shall not want. It would be a great place for fasting, too. Beware of the other guests. Admire the 3 orchids in the hall! They’re beautiful.
This was an exceptional stay. Exceptional. Omar and Mohammed at the front door/valet were so friendly and kind, and quite efficient in taking care of our family of 4 needs. The locations of the hotel is prime, making Times Square, Rockefeller Plaza, Broadway, Central Park and Upper East side easily accessible. Room service was wonderful with many different choices and expedient service.
Our room was large, very comfortable, and extremely clean. Only minor and expected street noise could be heard on the 15th floor.
Hector and the rest of the staff made our NYC trip easy, friendly, and comfortable. Thank you so much, you have made a dedicated Omni patron out of me!
The Madison suite is amazing. Highly recommend it. Berkshire suite was also nice. The Cathedral suite room 1430 was a big disappointment. When booking the room, the website shows a gorgeous unobstructed view of Saint Patrick's cathedral. But in reality there was a huge water tower massively obstructing the view!! See pic where I tried to position my daughter to hide the water tower with her body LOL. I paid a premium for that room because I wanted that view and it was definitely not what I was expecting based on the website photos. Seriously false advertising for that room. Location of hotel in midtown is great. All of the staff we encountered throughout our stay were kind and helpful except for one front desk person. Beds were comfortable. Overall a very positive experience. I would definitely stay again!
Waldorf Astoria New York
| Address | 301 Park Ave, New York, NY 10022 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | — |
| Phone | (212) 355-3000 |
I took my mother to New York City to celebrate her 65th birthday, and as first-time guests at the Waldorf Astoria, our experience was nothing short of incredible. From the moment we arrived, the entire team went above and beyond to make the milestone unforgettable.
The first-class hospitality started right at the curb with Joe, who gave us a warm welcome and took excellent care of our luggage. Checking in was just as seamless thanks to Miriam at the front desk, who gave us a wonderful tour of the property and surprised us with the best room possible for our celebration—even with the hotel being extremely booked from the tennis tournament over the previous days.
Our housekeeper, Kilsing, was exceptionally professional; every single time we returned to our room, it felt completely brand new, no matter what time of day it was. We also ran into Gordon several times throughout the hotel, and he was consistently helpful with directions and personally made sure we got exactly where we needed to go.
The dining experiences throughout the property were phenomenal:
* Peacock Alley: An iconic, beautiful setting that set the tone for our trip.
* Lex Yard: Ken provided unmatched expertise and attentive service that made our meal truly standout.
* Yoshoku: Jimmie was an exceptional server who made our dinner feel extra special.
We finished off the trip at the Guerlain Wellness Spa, where every single member of the staff was excellent, leaving us feeling completely relaxed and energized before our departure.
Every detail of our first visit reflected genuine luxury and top-tier service. We wouldn’t consider staying anywhere else in NYC and already look forward to returning!
My daughter and I had a little staycation here, and it was such a lovely experience. We were upgraded to a room with a view overlooking Park Ave, which made the stay feel extra special. The staff were warm, courteous, and genuinely helpful. Service throughout was excellent.
Our room was spacious and the bed was incredibly comfortable. Once I laid down, I truly didn’t want to get up.
The biggest surprise, in a good way, was breakfast. We ordered in-room dining because we didn’t feel like getting dressed to go downstairs, and I wasn’t expecting much. But the food was actually very good. It was a bit pricey, but the portions were generous. It took a little longer than expected to arrive and one salad was missing, but they brought it up after we called. Overall, we were pleasantly surprised by the quality.
There was also a small billing issue after checkout, which they resolved quickly. After we left, I realized I had forgotten my AirPods, and they located them within about 10 minutes of me reaching out. I was impressed by how quickly they handled it.
All in all, it was a very pleasant stay, and I would definitely come back.
The Waldorf Astoria is, by far, my favorite hotel in New York City. Its location is unbeatable, the lobby is absolutely stunning, and the level of hospitality is second to none.
A special thank you to Robert, the Sales Manager, who is one of the most professional, respectful, and genuinely hospitable people I’ve had the pleasure of meeting. His attention to detail and warm welcome make every stay even more memorable.
The rooms are consistently spotless, and I love how thoughtfully designed they are. The modern technology—such as the automatic curtains that open and close at the touch of a button—adds both luxury and convenience, a feature that many other five-star hotels still lack. Throughout the hotel, staff members are always attentive, proactively offering directions and checking whether guests need anything.
My only recommendation for future guests is to request a room that does not face Park Avenue if you’re a light sleeper. Traffic noise and occasional honking can be heard from those rooms. Other than that, every stay has been exceptional, and I look forward to returning.
I’d been here for dinner a few times before, but this was our first stay.
The room was absolutely beautiful, elegant and luxurious, yet warm and comfortable at the same time. It felt more like a high-end residence than a hotel. I think it’s a style many women would especially appreciate.
The bathroom was lovely, and I really enjoyed the toiletries as well.
The housekeeping staff were wonderful whenever I requested amenities. The front desk was New York, haha.
The gym was modern and stylish, with a long, open layout.
I’d definitely love to stay here again!
We had a recent experience at the NY Waldorf which was well below the standard we’ve come to expect .
My husband and I have come to love the property, and it has become our go-to for NYC. The Peacock bar is a beautiful place for a pre-dinner cocktail or a nightcap, and we have always found the staff to be professional and service oriented. The concierge service sets an industry gold standard.
My last visit unfortunately was a disappointment, and it was perhaps our most important visit. It was a small gathering amongst family and friends to celebrate my sister’s upcoming wedding. While not a “bachelorette party”, we had made some nice plans for dinners and rooftop bars in the city.
When we checked in - we were told our room was not ready. The manager on duty - Noah - informed us it should be ready soon. As the hours passed, all the way until 6 pm - still without being able to check in, and get ready for our evening - we got the feeling Noah was just “blowing smoke”. We wished for a more candid assessment at our arrival - such that we could have planned around the fact that our suite was still not ready more than 2 hours after check in time.
I’ll add that prior and during the visit, the concierge staff did live up to its usual excellence - and helped us make plans on many fronts.
We are hopeful that the next time we stay, we can have our room available in a timely manner, and receive honest assessments from management if issues do occur.
The St. Regis New York
| Address | Two E 55th St, New York, NY 10022 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | — |
| Phone | (212) 753-4500 |
I had an amazing stay at The St. Regis New York. As expected, the St. Regis brand lived up to its reputation and delivered a truly luxurious experience.
From the moment I walked into the room, I was impressed. The decor was beautiful and elegant, with the perfect mix of old-world charm and modern comfort. Even though the hotel has such a rich history dating back to 1904, the room did not feel outdated at all. Everything was incredibly well maintained, thoughtfully designed, and luxurious without feeling excessive or overdone.
One thing I was really looking forward to was trying the room service, and it ended up being one of the highlights of my stay. The lobster salad was absolutely phenomenal, the fries were honestly some of the best I’ve had, and the chocolate mousse was so good that I would happily order all three again on my next visit.
I was also very excited to visit the King Cole Bar, especially since it is the birthplace of the original Red Snapper cocktail, which later became known around the world as the Bloody Mary. The bar itself is beautiful, with incredible artwork, a classic New York atmosphere, and so much character. Of course, I had to try the famous cocktail, and it did not disappoint. It was the perfect drink to enjoy in such an iconic setting.
My only regret is that I didn’t wake up in time to experience breakfast at the hotel. After seeing how impressive the rest of the dining experience was, I have a feeling it would have been just as memorable.
Overall, The St. Regis New York was everything I hoped it would be: elegant, welcoming, and full of history while still feeling fresh and luxurious. I would absolutely stay here again.
It’s an oldie! And with age comes some wrinkles. Little to no AC in hallways and elevators. Shower was strong and great. Staff great. Room well appointed, but old. I’m just not feeling 1,500.oo - 2,000.oo a night for this one. Lots of history, great bar, The Ole King Cole, awesome bartender Adam. Breakfast was solid too. All in all for the price I just feel there are other options, but it is a great old hotel.
Fab stop for an afternoon glass of wine! Lovely and on point service. Breathtaking flower arrangements and a very thoughtful member of staff noticed us commenting on it and shared that these are done in house and showed us the flower room. The hotel is steeped in history and this is in display everywhere. Really loved it to its name!
My friend and I stopped into the St. Regis Hotel in NYC for a drink, and we were lucky enough to be served by Jessie. From the very first moment, she made us feel truly special and welcome — like longtime regulars rather than visitors popping in for a quick stop.
What truly set Jessie apart was her incredible warmth and the way she shared stories from her 30 years working at the St. Regis. Hearing her experiences was fascinating and made our visit so much richer. She has such genuine passion for her job and for making guests feel cared for — it shines through in every interaction. Her kindness, professionalism, and personal touch turned a simple drink into a memorable highlight of our time in New York City.
Jessie, you are a truly special person and an absolute gem. Thank you for the wonderful experience and the wonderful conversation! We’ll definitely be back, and we’ll be asking for your section every time.
If you’re visiting the St. Regis, make sure you sit with Jessie — she’ll make your visit unforgettable. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I decided to splurge and use a huge chunk of points to stay at my first ever St. Regis. To say it was a let down would be an understatement. For starters, when we arrived - no one greeted us. We pulled up to the front of the hotel, retrieved our luggage from the cab, and a doorman came out and asked if the bellman had assisted us. We said no, and he proceeded to try to locate him. We took the bags ourselves.
Upon reaching the front desk (Friday at approx 5pm), the woman barely looked up. I initiated conversation by saying hello and providing my ID. She gave no details about the room or property. Once the bellman brought our bags up, he brought with him a pungent trail of cigarette smoke. Then, as we were getting ready for dinner, the housekeeper ENTERED THE ROOM without prior knocking or warning. She did not apologize, simply asked if we wanted turndown service which we immediately said no and asked her to leave.
When we were finally getting to sleep that night, the sheets carried a terrible musty odor. They smelt like the sheets had been left damp for too long before being dried. The following day we kindly left a note asking they be changed and to no surprise, they were not. All in all, I feel completely let down and like it was a huge waste of points. I've stayed at several lesser quality Marriotts and never had any issues, so this felt monumentally disappointing.
DoubleTree by Hilton New York Midtown Fifth Ave
| Address | 25 W 51st St, New York, NY 10019 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | — |
| Phone | (212) 262-3200 |
The hotel is in a perfect location for walking to Times Square, Broadway, Central Park, and the Fifth Avenue shops. Sharmayne and Jaziah at the front desk were outstanding, both incredibly welcoming, warm, and genuinely attentive from the moment I arrived. They made check-in smooth and effortless and were always smiling, upbeat, and ready to help with anything I needed. Their professionalism and kindness really stood out and made me feel valued as a guest. Customer service like theirs is rare and truly among the best I have experienced.
The room was spacious and clean, which made for a comfortable stay. I would definitely stay here again on my next visit to New York.
This is a Motel6 with a Hilton wrapper. I am Hilton Diamond and fully support and enjoy my Hilton stays. Every aspect of this hotel falls short of the brand. My room was barely larger than my queen bed. There was one clothes drawer for two people. Hilton is great about morning coffee - none. There is usually a comfortable place to chat - none. The food ($) allowance barely covered a bowl of yogurt. Hilton is usually good about providing water - nope and it was $4.50 per bottle. My usual reviews are positive and objective about the experience. This was unpleasant. The room typically was not cleaned until 4pm. Our last evening was closer to 7pm and so we just asked for towels. My advice - DO NOT STAY here.
UPDATE: I just called the number that they provided and it never answered. I also went to the web link that they provided and it was a generic help page and had nothing to do with Customer Service.
Fantastic location! Easy walk or subway ride to all of the main attractions in Manhattan. The room was smallish and laid out a bit weird, but the bed was very comfortable and clean. Everything seemed pretty new. The bathroom was a bit cramped but had all of the basics. The AC was fabulous and the temperature was easy to control. The front desk staff was helpful, friendly, and efficient. The elevators could be a bit slow but overall were fine. The view from our second floor room was, we'll, not inspiring, but we were happy to have the blackout shade at night. Overall a great experience for our first trip to NY.
Unwelcome feeling. People working at reception were having inapproriote music on while coming into the hotel. Requested a room in the app; one of the perks of being a member and booking direct; requested high floor front facing, received side facing low floor. No option to switch to a better room. Why do they let me choose a room and just dont give it?! I know i can change; but why let me choose in the first place? Room was fine but airconditioning didnt properly work during the day. Felt warm, moist and sticky in the room. Stinky also.
Lobby often very busy with guests and guests of the restaurant. Long waiting times at the elevators.
During checkout the standard discussion about the food and beverage credit. Wasnt applied correctly. Had no time to discuss it longer had tk catch my flight. Elevators had a weird smell. Hallways very anonymous. Elevators could be used by anyone, not roomkey activated. Not a safe feeling.
This property is in my opinion not upto Hilton/doubletree standards. A no go for us next time. Restaurant also lacks in quality. Burnt food, standard applied service charge and lacking in proper service.
It's hard to find a NY hotel with decent reviews, but this one delivered! Amazing location, nice clean rooms, and excellent daily housekeeping. Walk out the front door, cross the street, and you're so Rockefeller Center. So many great bars and restaurants in every direction.
New York Hilton Midtown
| Address | 1335 6th Ave, New York, NY 10019 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | — |
| Phone | (212) 586-7000 |
Gio made our stay absolutely perfect! We love coming to Midtown, and honestly, he’s a big reason why. Gio made sure every need was met and then some, and he truly went above and beyond to make our stay special.
My fiancé and I absolutely loved our room. It was huge, spotless, and had an amazing view. The bed was so comfortable and made it easy to relax after a long day. The food was amazing as well and made the experience even better.
The elevator system was very easy to use and understand, which made getting around the hotel effortless. We also really enjoyed the Diamond Lounge. It was very nice, and the staff there were incredibly helpful and welcoming.
Everyone we spoke with throughout our stay was friendly and helpful. Overall, we had an amazing experience and can’t wait to come back!
My stay at Hilton Midtown New York was outstanding from start to finish. Every part of my experience exceeded my expectations. The room was spotless, comfortable, and well-maintained, and the entire hotel had a welcoming, upscale atmosphere. The customer service was truly five-star—every employee I encountered was friendly, professional, and genuinely helpful.
I was in New York for Jay-Z’s three-night concert weekend, and staying here made the trip even more memorable. After long days and exciting nights, it was a pleasure returning to such a clean, relaxing, and well-managed hotel.
I also had dinner at the hotel restaurant and ordered the salmon, which was absolutely superb. It was one of the highlights of my stay and a great dining experience.
I don’t know the hotel’s official star rating, but it honestly felt like a seven-star experience. The level of hospitality, attention to detail, and overall excellence made me feel valued as a guest from check-in to check-out.
A heartfelt thank you to everyone on the staff for making my visit so enjoyable. Your professionalism and kindness did not go unnoticed. This level of service is a true testament to the outstanding leadership and management at Hilton Midtown New York. Keep up the incredible work—I will gladly stay here again and highly recommend this hotel to anyone visiting New York City.
Skip. It. I hate to say this, but there are far better hotels in the area. It is in a convenient location to Midtown, but that's about it. The hotel is huge, which makes it pretty surprising there aren't really any good food options on site. There are three areas in the lobby, but one was closed when I was there. One is a grab-and-go type sandwich/pastry booth, and the last offers a continental breakfast that is around $40 and the ryoival fare would would find at Hamptons Inn for free: fruit, yogurt, muffins, eggs etc.
The elevators are currently being renovated and hit or miss. They can take awhile to arrive.
As for the rooms. I was actually surprised at how large my room was. Especially for NYC. But it was in need if a little TLC. The chair was very worn, the light flickered, and there was no hot water the 2nd morning.
I will say that at the staff gets 5 stars. The bellmen were helpful and friendly. The concierge suggested a very nice Italian restaurant around the corner for dinner (Il Corso).
But overall, I wouldn't suggest staying at the New York Hilton Midtown.
Four stars because the rooms are dated. But felt inclined to write this review because location was perfect, and staff was fabulous! I read some reviews prior to arriving that made me nervous but everyone we met was more than accommodating. Especially Ali (bell hop), who helped us with our luggage during check out. 11/10 customer service! So kind and helpful. Other than that, yes the elevators were annoying at times but overall were manageable. Just had to wait a few minutes during peak hours and this was with the hotel sold out for the US open. Really wasn’t end of the world like some of these reviews make it to be. Overall- I would come back and stay just for the quality of the staff alone. Upgrade those rooms to Hilton quality and this would have been a 5/5 stay.
First time visiting. The staff was amazing, aside from the pushy Hilton honors people who try to accost you as you’re walking through the lobby. The beds were mediocre, and had I had a say in where we stayed, this would not have been it. The bathroom had zero ventilation, so anything put in there was consistently damp from the shower, even with the door left open. The towel rod was coming out of the wall and no matter how far away we placed the bath mat, it always got wet, because the ADA accessible shower did not have correct sloping. Speaking of ADA, the seat for our mobility challenged friend was hard to get down and she never put it back up because she was afraid she wouldn’t be able to get it back down.
The elevators were sketchy, sometimes they worked, sometimes you got kept from using them completely. They were working on them throughout our entire 4 nights there and one of those nights we got blocked from using the elevators that go to our specific floor. We were happy to use the service elevators, that we had been assured we could use at any time, and that was the only moment we had any attitude or pushback from any staff. We were on the 23rd floor with a mobility scooter and he tried to tell us we could not use them but changed his mind when we pushed back.
The AC unit needed a filter change and they put four of us in a room that should have been for two, according to the AC maintenance person. He was lovely and got a fan sent up, which helped, but the room never cooled down enough to be comfortable, especially in the sticky heat outside.
It may have just been the one room, but it was not a great experience for me or my roommates and I hope they consider doing some upgrades, considering how much they charge for rooms, even in midtown.
3 West Club
| Address | 3 W 51st St, New York, NY 10019 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 7:00 AM – 12:00 AM Tuesday: 7:00 AM – 12:00 AM Wednesday: 7:00 AM – 12:00 AM Thursday: 7:00 AM – 12:00 AM Friday: 7:00 AM – 12:00 AM Saturday: 7:00 AM – 12:00 AM Sunday: 7:00 AM – 12:00 AM |
| Phone | (212) 582-5454 |
We had an absolutely wonderful experience at this hotel, and we cannot say enough good things about James at the front desk.
We arrived in an incredibly stressful situation after another hotel cancelled our reservation on the day of our arrival, without any warning, leaving us scrambling to find somewhere to stay and genuinely worried that we would be left without a place to sleep. We showed up to this hotel in desperation, and thankfully James was there to help. He went above and beyond to accommodate us and gave us the last available room in the entire hotel.
The room was lovely, the hotel was comfortable, and the staff were wonderful, but James truly deserves special recognition. Customer service like this is rare, and we are so grateful that he was there when we needed help most.
Thank you, James, for turning an incredibly stressful situation into one we will actually remember fondly. We would absolutely stay here again and would highly recommend this hotel to anyone!
Picked the 3 West Club because of the location and their historical registration status and wow! Morning breakfast on the solarium balcony with a view of Saint Patrick’s Cathedral…the historical drawings, paintings, and portraits on the wall, the various entertainment rooms were all great…
But the real win was the service and the employees. They were respectful and attentive without being stiff and unfriendly. Great vibe.
The rooms were solid. Fine historical furniture that functioned and was sturdy, air conditioning via quiet heat pumps worked well, and the water tasted good.
We will be back!
Beautiful. Old school club with a big room for private events at the second floor also with the rooftop view at the 9th floor. We had a blast connecting with old and new colleagues as well enjoyed the drinks and appetizers prepared by the team. Can't wait to be back for different kind of events. Highly recommend for special occasions and events.
My husband and I stayed here from March 4-7 2026. I can't say I've ever slept in a more comfortable hotel bed - literally no back pain. We walked up to 9 miles a day (not including all the museums and places we went that Google wasn't tracking).
The staff was nice and suggested places to get good food/breakfast, and the closest place is incase you forgot your toothpaste like we did.
Definitely go check out the fancy rooms and the balcony if they aren't being used. Love the view!
Great location and it's quick to get around midtown or down to the subway if you're going farther. And it's very easy to find the right street with such big, easy to spot buildings on the same street.
-Only negative is that there isn't two chairs in the room so if you're both eating in the hotel room, one person has to sit on the bed, or stand. But we only did that once or twice. I don't think it would be worth the space to have another chair, but just something to note.
My daughter and I had an amazing stay at 3 West Club; we had a very nice welcoming by Christ and all the staff were very attentive. The maids made a wonderful work and they are really helpful. The location was perfect almost in front of Saint Patrick Cathedral. I think is one of the best hotels in Midtown. Thanks to all of them
Hilton Club The Central at 5th New York
| Address | 12 E 48th St, New York, NY 10017 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | — |
| Phone | (646) 869-8900 |
I come to NYC every summer for work, and The Central is always my first choice for accommodations. For a mid-priced hotel, it has all the little luxury amenities you would usually find at a 5 star hotel, but for a fraction of the price.
While the rooms are normal-sized the bathrooms are huge. Full walk-in shower, instant hot water, full vanity with plenty of space for me to lay out my toiletries, magnifying mirror, and the main mirror is giant and has a bright backlight. In addition to standard toiletries, they also provide mouthwash, makeup remover wipes, and body lotion.
The rooms themselves have plenty of closet space and plenty of drawers, which some NYC hotels lack, not to mention really nice bathrobes. There’s a mini fridge and coffee maker, as well as a full sized desk, and accessible, working plugs on each side of the bed. The floor to ceiling windows provide a gorgeous view of the city, and the motorized blackout shades make the room pitch black when sleeping.
The hotel has a small gym that is always clean. The front desk is staffed 24/7 and I’ve never seen a line more than 2 guests deep. Most importantly the employees who work here are genuinely friendly, experienced, and helpful. The cleaning staff is meticulous. Once, my AC was not working all full power. I didn’t even notice, but the cleaning staff called maintenance and they fixed it within an hour.
I hate being away from home for so long, but The Central makes my stay feel almost like home, just with daily housekeeping 🙂
We stayed here for the July 4 holiday weekend. Nice place though a bit pricey. Rooms are bigger than a regular NY City place. Modern layout too.
They have very attentive staff and has messaging feature even late in the evening. Housekeeping is outstanding. Our room was well kept by Nikila. She provided great service!
A few things to note: Hilton Club does not honor your Hilton status. We hoped for an upgrade considering the place was not fully booked but couldn't get it with our gold status. We also hoped for a late checkout but it was rejected. I think it was Elvis who sits at the far right. He is a bit strict and stern looking (doesn't smile at all). Everyone else were friendly especially the nice gentleman who checked us in late July 2nd. Not sure if I remember his name correctly (I think Alexander(?)). He is the same person who texted with us when I notified them we were arriving close to midnight. Very friendly and accommodating guy.
The location is perfect if you want to be near Rockefeller, Central Park, Grand Central, etc. the hotel is surprisingly quiet, aside from nearby construction at the time of our visit; crews worked through the night.
The staff is fantastic - exceptionally welcoming and friendly. Rooms, lobby, and elevators are very clean with cleaning service daily. It’s important to know this location does not serve breakfast, but Tartinery Café at Grand Central is a fantastic option. Plenty of restaurants nearby and shopping on Fifth Avenue.
We would stay here again, but it’s worth noting the WiFi wasn’t great (don’t plan to work at the hotel). Otherwise, thank you for a wonderful week in NYC.
I’m giving this hotel 5 stars for size and cleanliness. I’ve stayed in plenty of hotels in NYC, and I really appreciated how spacious the rooms are at Hilton Club The Central at 5th. In a city where room size can be hit or miss (mostly miss), this was a huge plus.
They also offer additional amenities upon request, which really came in handy. My wife forgot her toothbrush, and housekeeping delivered a toothbrush, toothpaste, and mouthwash to our room shortly after we called the front desk.
The staff was friendly and accommodating throughout our stay. With a 10AM checkout, it was great that they held our luggage while we ran a few errands before heading out.
Location-wise, it’s perfect if you’re in town for entertainment. We were about a 15-minute drive from Lincoln Center’s David H. Koch Theater, a 12-minute walk to the Lunt-Fontanne Theater, walking distance to Times Square and 5th Ave shopping, and just a 3-minute walk to the train (we used the orange line’s F train).
Overall, clean, comfortable, spacious, and convenient. I absolutely plan on staying here again.
Is a great Quality/Price hotel.
Rooms are nice and well furnished, bathrooms are excellent equipped also with japanese TOTO toilets, great shower space.
The room is quiet small, but big enough.
The Gym is awful, a lack of respect to it gym, is a sapce with 3 things inside...
I will return the next trip to NYC!!
Park Central Hotel New York
| Address | 870 7th Ave, New York, NY 10019 |
|---|---|
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | — |
| Phone | (212) 247-8000 |
We got the room with 2 queen beds. It has space for the beds and not much else. Bathroom is nice. We got continental breakfast included (1 coffee, 1 pastry, 1 whole fruit), not the best but manageable. People cleaning the rooms are very nice and helpful. People in the front desks and breakfast service seem to be set on proving the rude new yorker stereotype. The location however, is hard to beat. All in all, if you want to be in a central location for tourism it is a very good place to be.
The location of the hotel is amazing, and the employees were friendly and helpful. There is a bar with live music past the lobby, and 2 new express elevators. When coming back down to the lobby I noticed I had to wait 1-3 minutes. The rooms are a little bit older, but they are definitely sufficient! Note that they run on a old AC system so they only have cool in the summer and only heating in the winter. Housekeeping came daily and was great. There is also an ice machine on each floor and a fitness center as well.
Disappointing Stay – Communication, Service and Guest Safety Concerns
Unfortunately, our stay at Park Central Hotel was quite disappointing. We were a family of four, and from the beginning of our stay, we experienced several issues with communication, service, and coordination between the hotel staff.
At check-in, complimentary toothbrushes, laundry bags, towels, shower cap and clothes hangers were not provided. As I had forgotten to pack toothbrushes, I contacted reception and politely requested three complimentary toothbrushes. I was told that housekeeping would bring them to our room. However, housekeeping initially brought only one toothbrush. After I explained that I had requested three, I was told that reception had instructed them to provide only one. After further checking, another toothbrush was eventually brought to us.
We also requested four laundry bags but were provided with only two small plastic bags.
The most concerning incident occurred later that night. I called reception to request some clothes hangers and was told that they were being collected and would be brought to our room. After waiting approximately 20 minutes, I called reception again. I was told that the staff were still collecting the hangers and was asked not to put up the "Do Not Disturb" sign so they could assist us. We waited for another 30 minutes, but no one came. As it was already around 10:30 pm, we eventually went to sleep.
Then, at approximately 2:30 am, someone knocked on our hotel room door. When I opened the door, I saw a person wearing a mask who told me that reception had informed him that our TV needed to be repaired. I explained that we had requested clothes hangers, not a TV repair. He then asked me to contact reception and let them know that he had come to assist with the TV.
This incident was particularly concerning and made us uncomfortable. From a guest's perspective, having an unknown person arrive at our room at 2:30 am claiming to be there to repair a TV raises genuine concerns about safety and security. It was especially confusing because we had never reported a problem with the TV. We feel that maintenance or room-service requests should be clearly communicated and that visits to guest rooms late at night should be handled with appropriate caution and verification.
In addition to these service issues, the hotel itself appears quite dated. The furniture is old, the rooms feel cramped for a family of four, and we noticed that there was no exhaust fan, which affected the overall comfort of the room. While we understand that the hotel may be an older property, better maintenance and some improvements to the facilities would make a significant difference to the guest experience.
We appreciate that misunderstandings can happen, and we hope the hotel management takes this feedback constructively. In particular, we believe there is room for improvement in communication between reception and housekeeping, follow-up on guest requests, room facilities, and procedures for approaching guest rooms late at night.
Most importantly, guest safety and security should always be a priority.
Unfortunately, based on our experience, we were disappointed with the level of customer service and overall comfort during our stay. We hope management will take these concerns seriously and use this feedback to improve the experience for future guests.
Overall pleasant experience at this hotel. All the staff were friendly and cooperative. Comfortable beds with multiple lamps within room; personally I prefer a more well-lit room. The rooms were in pretty high demand, so it is recommended to book ahead of time. The first room we were given had a scent of mildew in the bathroom. We changed rooms the next day and there was no problem with our new room. It is in pretty close proximity to central park and many other nice tourist attractions such as Time Square and the Empire State Building. Also there is a kind man at the entrance of the hotel who can help you call a taxi whenever you need one!
We had a great stay at Park Central Hotel New York! The location is definitely one of its biggest perks. It’s very close to Central Park, Times Square, shopping, and tons of restaurants. It’s also really easy to get around from the hotel, whether you’re taking the subway, grabbing a taxi, or calling an Uber.
The hotel lounge is a nice area to hang out, and every employee we interacted with was incredibly friendly—from reception and the bell staff to the doormen and housekeeping. We stayed on the 10th floor and had a decent view overlooking the street. Despite being in such a busy part of the city, it wasn’t too loud at night and we had no issues sleeping.
The rooms are a little outdated and could probably use some updating, and our TV glitched quite a bit during the stay. Those were relatively minor issues for us, though. Overall, we had a great stay and really enjoyed the convenient location and friendly service. I’d definitely recommend it if you want to be centrally located while visiting NYC!
Tips for Choosing the Best Hotel Near St. Patrick’s Cathedral
Before you finalize your reservation, it is wise to consider a few strategic factors that can significantly impact the quality of your trip. The Midtown area is dense, and while many hotels claim to be "central," the specific block and building orientation can change your experience. Understanding the local landscape, from pedestrian traffic to noise levels, will help you select a property that feels like a retreat rather than a chaotic hub. Here are essential tips to guide your decision-making process.
Consider the View and Orientation
When staying near a landmark as iconic as St. Patrick’s Cathedral, the view from your window matters. Many travelers assume they will automatically see the spires, but high-rise buildings often obstruct sightlines. If a view of the cathedral or the surrounding Midtown skyline is important to you, call the hotel directly to request a high-floor room on the correct side of the building. However, be aware that higher floors facing the street can sometimes amplify the hum of the city, so request a room away from the elevator banks for maximum quiet.
Look Beyond the Base Room Rate
The sticker price of a hotel room in Midtown Manhattan is rarely the final amount you will pay. Most properties in this prime district charge mandatory "destination fees" or "resort fees" that cover amenities like Wi-Fi, gym access, or local calling. Before comparing prices, read the fine print to understand the total nightly cost. Additionally, factor in the cost of breakfast; some hotels offer packages that include dining credits, which can save you a significant amount compared to buying a la carte meals in Midtown.
Evaluate the Lobby and Elevator Traffic
Hotels near major tourist attractions often double as event venues or popular spots for lobby bars, attracting non-guests. While a vibrant lobby can be exciting, it can also lead to crowded elevators and longer wait times, especially during the holiday season when the Rockefeller Center tree is lit. If you value peace and quiet, prioritize boutique hotels or properties with separate, private elevator banks for guests. Reading recent reviews for mentions of "crowded lobby" or "slow elevators" can save you from frustration.
Assess Proximity to Public Transit
While walking to St. Patrick’s Cathedral is your primary goal, you will likely want to explore other parts of the city, such as the Financial District or the Upper West Side. Being near the cathedral puts you close to the 5 Av/53 St subway station (E and M trains) and the 47-50 Sts-Rockefeller Ctr station (B, D, F, and M trains). Ensure your chosen hotel offers easy access to these lines. This will make your trip to Central Park or the theatre district much faster than relying on taxis or rideshares, which often get stuck in Fifth Avenue gridlock.
Check for Seasonal Noise and Renovations
New York is a city that constantly reinvents itself, and Midtown is the epicenter of construction. Before booking, check recent guest reviews for mentions of street noise, scaffolding, or adjacent building work. A hotel that was perfectly quiet six months ago might be facing a jackhammer today. Furthermore, if you are visiting during the winter holidays, be prepared for massive crowds directly outside the hotel doors; if you have mobility issues or dislike crowds, you might prefer a hotel a few blocks east or west of the immediate Fifth Avenue corridor.
Staying near St. Patrick’s Cathedral offers more than just a convenient address; it places you within the beating heart of Manhattan’s most iconic scenery. The ability to step outside your hotel and immediately be greeted by the cathedral’s intricate facade and the energy of Fifth Avenue is a distinct privilege. Whether you choose a legendary grand dame or a sleek modern tower, the key is finding a space that feels like your own private haven in the sky.
As you finalize your plans, remember that the best hotel is one that aligns with your personal travel rhythm. Prioritize the amenities that matter most to you, whether that is a 24-hour fitness center, a world-class concierge, or simply an exceptionally comfortable bed. With the right accommodation, your visit to St. Patrick’s Cathedral will be elevated from a simple sightseeing stop to the centerpiece of a truly luxurious New York City experience.
