Chicago’s Italian dining scene is more than just a collection of restaurants; it is a living, breathing archive of family tradition, immigration history, and culinary evolution. From the historic red-sauce joints of Little Italy to the sleek, modern pasta labs in the West Loop, the city offers a staggering depth of flavor. Whether you are craving a perfectly charred Neapolitan pizza or a delicate, hand-cut tajarin, the Windy City delivers an Italian experience that rivals the boot itself.
Navigating this dense culinary landscape can be overwhelming, especially with new hotspots opening every month while legacy institutions continue to hold their ground. The key to understanding Chicago Italian food lies in recognizing its diversity. It is not just spaghetti and meatballs; it is about regional specificity, from Sicilian seafood to Tuscan steaks and Roman carbonara.
For locals and visitors alike, the search for the "best" often depends on the occasion. A romantic date night requires a different atmosphere than a boisterous family gathering or a quick pre-theater bite. Fortunately, Chicago’s geography ensures that a world-class plate of pasta is never too far away, whether you are in River North, Lincoln Park, or the suburbs bordering the city limits.
In curating this list, we have focused on consistency, ingredient quality, and the intangible "soul" that separates a good restaurant from a truly memorable one. We have considered the mastery of the chefs, the warmth of the service, and the ability to transport diners to Italy without a plane ticket. These establishments represent the pinnacle of Italian cuisine in the city today.
We understand that "best" is subjective, but certain standards are universal: pasta should be cooked to a perfect al dente, sauces should be balanced and bright, and the bread should be worth the carbs. The restaurants featured below have proven time and again that they understand these non-negotiables. They are the places we recommend to our closest friends and the spots we crave on a cold Chicago night.
This guide is designed to be evergreen, highlighting establishments that have established deep roots and reputations for excellence rather than fleeting trends. You will find a mix of Michelin-starred destinations and beloved neighborhood trattorias. Each offers a unique window into the vast world of Italian gastronomy.
As you plan your culinary journey, remember that reservations are often essential, particularly for weekend dining. But whether you secure a table at a white-tablecloth icon or grab a stool at a bustling wine bar, the Italian spirit of hospitality—ospitalità—is waiting to welcome you.
Quartino Ristorante

| Address | 626 N State St, Chicago, IL 60654 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:30 AM – 12:30 AM
Tuesday: 11:30 AM – 12:30 AM
Wednesday: 11:30 AM – 12:30 AM
Thursday: 11:30 AM – 12:30 AM
Friday: 11:30 AM – 12:30 AM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 12:30 AM
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 12:30 AM |
| Phone | (312) 698-5000 |
Kelly Cho★★★★★
Our first here was amazing! The food was great, service was incredible, and every dish came out quickly. I’d def recommend this place! I had caprese, tagliatelle alla bolognese, taligliata di manzo(steak), funghi pizza, caprese, tiramisu, and they were all so delicious! Shout out to our server, Eric, for being so accommodating and excellent! He was the cherry on top at the restaurant.
Leo Z★★★★★
Lots of places were fully booked for valentines, but quartinos had lots of availability and it was definitely a worth experience.
The pizza was amazing, soft and good flavor. Prices for all dishes were reasonable for the amount of food you get unlike most places. The salad was delicious and the beef pasta (i forget the exact name) pictured below was also nice and hot right out of the kitchen.
The risotto was okay, well cooked but probably just not my thing.
I would definitely recommend the pizza here and next time would get more pizza rather than the pasta + risotto but still very good.
Service was nice and even though it was busy we had very little wait time for our food and service
Reyna Alam★★★★★
I’ve been twice, and had a lovely experience both times. There tends to always be people inside, but they are still very accommodating of walk-ins (took in our two groups of 7 on a Sunday night). Definitely recommend reserving if you can, though. Service is an A+ just for our waiter teaching us how to fix our cheese grater.
In terms of the food, I’d note that the pastas don’t really feel like shareable portion sizes but the pizzas are more substantial. However, the ingredients taste really fresh and good quality so I’d say it’s worth ordering more (highlights for us were the gnocchi, fettuccine alfredo, penne alla vodka, clam linguini, funghi pizza, and the shrimp risotto). Prices are still pretty affordable when splitting with a group too. Overall a great spot, and the vibes when they had the World Cup playing were unmatched.
Sean O'Brien★★★★★
Simply an amazing place to eat. Since it was small plates we did a sampling. Every single thing was outstanding. It was easily one of the best meals of my life. Special shout out to our server, Ryan, who added exponentially to the experience and truly made this an evening that my wife and I will remember for a very long time.
Melissa Quarles★★★★★
Definitely worth the price. Excellent food, top tier service, great selection of wine and authentic Italian food. Our server Lulu was wonderful.
Update: We decided to come here a second time. The food here is just excellent. Service is swift and friendly.
Alla Vita

| Address | 564 W Randolph St, Chicago, IL 60661 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM, 4:30 – 10:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM, 4:30 – 10:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM, 4:30 – 10:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM, 4:30 – 10:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM, 4:30 – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 4:30 – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 4:30 – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (312) 667-0104 |
Alejandro Gutierrez★★★★★
Been dying to try alla vita for years, and on this trip we celebrated a birthday. I have to say Alla vita really made it memorable. Through the reservation I made ahead of time I let them know it was a birthday celebration. They customized the menu to read happy birthday to my partner which she loved. They also gave her a delightful sweet treat (ice cream with a candle) cant thank them enough for this.
The service was amazing, but what's a review if not for the food itself. The wood fires table bread was great. The sweet honey glaze really gave it a good flavor. The meatballs were okay, not bad but definitely skippable. The taste was that of a basic meat load. The margarita pizza was also just okay, I think I should've gone with one which had toppings to throw on some real flavor. The real winner was the chicken parmigiana. Paired with some rigatoni on the side, amazing.
Overall a great experience for a special0 event, dont regret reserving a table here at all
Janvi P.★★★★☆
The service and food were amazing! I went for a birthday dinner with my friends and the staff was so accommodating and sweet! This was a very carb heavy meal for all of us, but the food was very savory. The wood fire bread was soft and delicious, the cheese filled arancini was my favorite appetizer it melted right in my mouth and was a mix of crunchy but soft! We got a margherita pizza for the table which was delicious but the rigatoni vodka pasta was my fav dinner dish! It was soft and flavorful, but I feel it could’ve been seasoned a bit better, not the best I’ve had but still a great rigatoni dish here - but either way It was still delicious and would highly recommend!
Eddy K★★★★★
SOLID
That’s what my cousin from New York City called it. I call it “excellence.” I had guests from out of state and decided to take them to dinner. I’m so glad I took them out to this spot. With the great reviews I read about and the looks of it, I was sure this was the spot I needed to be. With a great location in the heart of Chicago, it was walking distance to the famous riverwalk. The inside of the restaurant has beautiful warm aesthetics and not to mention a beautifully designed ceiling decor.
Now as far as the food goes, they have an amazing authentic menu. From the beautifully tasteful calamari, to the delicious mushroom pizza, the chef had us eager to try our entrees. I had the chicken parmigiana. The chicken breast was well cooked and Parmesan sauce was beyond delicious. My wife had another dish that was made with hand made pasta and she loved it. Portions are well worth the money spent. It was a pricey dinner but well worth it. The waiters and servers are very friendly and knowledgeable with the menu. They catered to our expectations and gave us a wonderful experience.
Dawn★★★★☆
I really want to give loved it because the food was amazing, but it was so loud in the restaurant from music and tables shouting to talk over the music.
The food tho? Some of the best pasta I have had in a hot minute. Their meatballs, delightful. Arancini, the best we had in the city over the week. Their Bolognese was a show stopper, best I have had in months, pasta cooked to perfection and the meat was incredibly tender and well seasoned. The olive oil strawberry rhubarb cake was superb!
Darren B.★★★★★
Absolutely a magical dinning experience. We felt like royalty with outstanding service, amazing cocktails and food that went beyond any expectations. Worth every dollar spent. I suggest multiple coarses and cocktails with a mindset to overindulge in the decadence.
Il Porcellino

| Address | 59 W Hubbard St #2, Chicago, IL 60654 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 4:00 – 9:30 PM
Tuesday: 4:00 – 9:30 PM
Wednesday: 4:00 – 9:30 PM
Thursday: 4:00 – 9:30 PM
Friday: 4:00 – 10:30 PM
Saturday: 4:00 – 10:30 PM
Sunday: 4:00 – 9:30 PM |
| Phone | (312) 595-0800 |
David Ren★★★★★
We had a wonderful dinner here and every dish we ordered was excellent.
We started with the Sausage and Peppers appetizer. The sausage was juicy and flavorful, paired with perfectly cooked sweet peppers and a delicious house-made sauce that brought everything together.
The Fresh Herb Fettuccine Alfredo was rich, creamy, and full of flavor. The fresh herbs added a wonderful aroma and made the dish feel fresh despite its rich, silky sauce.
The Burrata Lasagna was another standout. The burrata made the lasagna incredibly creamy, while the layers of pasta, meat, and cheese were perfectly balanced. Every bite was comforting and satisfying.
The Sliced Pepper Steak Grigliata was cooked perfectly. The steak was tender, juicy, and flavorful, and the grilled peppers were the perfect accompaniment.
The service was warm, attentive, and professional throughout the evening. The restaurant also has a beautiful atmosphere that made the dining experience even more enjoyable. A fantastic place for a memorable Italian meal.
Nicole Bell★★★★★
We ended up at Porcellino’s after missing our reservation at another restaurant, and honestly, it turned out to be one of the best surprises of our trip! The lasagna was hands down one of the best I’ve ever had; rich, comforting, and absolutely unforgettable. And whatever you do, order the whole loaf of garlic bread. Trust me, it’s a must.
Everything we had was delicious, the cocktails were perfectly made, the ambiance was warm and inviting, and the service was fantastic. Sometimes the best meals happen by accident, and this was definitely one of them. We’d absolutely recommend it and can’t wait to come back!
Wolfpack (The Wolfpack)★★★★★
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Outstanding Service & Incredible Food!
We had an absolutely amazing dining experience, and a huge part of that was thanks to our server, Ana. She was attentive, welcoming, and made sure our evening was perfect.
The food was top-tier. The seven-layer homemade lasagna was a masterpiece—rich bolognese in between every single layer, baked perfectly with creamy, melted burrata cheese on top. We finished with the Spumoni sundae, which was incredible. The marbled cherry, chocolate, and pistachio ice cream topped with real Luxardo cherries and crunchy pistachios was the perfect ending.
Fantastic food and flawless service from Ana. We will definitely be back!
Naz★★★★★
So good! We went in to celebrate a belated Valentine’s Day. Our server was attentive and responsive to questions. The food was phenomenal. The star of the show were the lasagna and meatballs. Alongside the chocolate cake for dessert. Vesuvio style potatoes was the only item we wouldn’t order again. Overall delicious and good service!
Charles Hardy Jr★★★★★
My first visit to Il Porcellino and everything was outstanding. The garlic bread with clarified butter is a must-order, and the pesto sauce is so good that you should get a side and put it on everything. Every dish was flavorful, well-executed, and clearly made with care.
The highlight of the evening was our server, Beatrice B. She was phenomenal—a true class act. Knowledgeable, warm, and genuinely friendly, she made us feel special from start to finish. Her enthusiasm for the menu was contagious and had us wanting to order everything. Exceptional food paired with exceptional service. Can’t wait to come back.
OLIO E PIÙ

| Address | 445 N Dearborn St, Chicago, IL 60654 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (312) 363-3335 |
Sunny Lan (HYL)★★★★☆
Great food and atmosphere! The meatballs, white wine clam pasta, and Aperol Spritz were all really good. The outdoor seating and half-open dining area are perfect for summer days.
The only downside was that the staff seemed to rush us a bit by clearing our table and bringing the check even though there were plenty of empty seats. Still, we really enjoyed the place and would definitely come back!
Liz Jing★★★★★
I had a wonderful experience at Olio e Più in Chicago. The atmosphere was beautiful and energetic, with a warm Italian vibe that made the entire evening feel special. The restaurant's elegant design and lively ambiance created the perfect setting for a night out.
The food was excellent, from the fresh house-made pasta to the thoughtfully prepared appetizers and desserts. Every dish was full of flavor and beautifully presented. The service was equally impressive—attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable without ever feeling rushed.
What stood out most was how the restaurant managed to combine authentic Italian cuisine with a welcoming, upscale dining experience. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying dinner with friends, Olio e Più is a fantastic choice. I will definitely be back and highly recommend it to anyone looking for great Italian food in Chicago.
NAT FED★★☆☆☆
I never write reviews, but the food here was so disappointing I had to write a review. We ordered a grilled octopus for appetizer, the dish had a lot of potatoes and sauce but very little octopus. For $27, that was a rip off. Then we ordered $32 scallop risotto. My scallops were tiny, burnt and rubbery, should’ve been called asparagus risotto because it had a ton more asparagus than scallops in it. Also had the lamb cavatelli $30, the sauce tasted as if it was out of a can, thin and watery. Lamb was barely to be found in that dish. Not sure if the food was this bad because it was a Sunday, but for the price it should be better. I kept looking over at RPM across the street and wishing I had gone there instead. Feel like this is a tourist trap with below average food.
Ambience and service were great, just wish the food was better.
Susan Kim★★★★★
We ended up here yesterday after another restaurant we wanted to try was fully booked, and I am so glad it worked out that way. There were about 15 minutes left of happy hour, so we grabbed a table on the patio, which was such a nice spot to sit and relax.
From the moment we walked in, everyone was incredibly welcoming. The hostess was so kind and even asked where we would prefer to sit, which was a small touch but really appreciated. Our waiter was just as friendly and attentive throughout the meal.
One thing I really loved was that we never felt rushed. We were able to enjoy our food, catch up, and just have a relaxed evening without feeling like we needed to hurry. Great service, a lovely patio, and an overall wonderful experience. We will definitely be back!
ARI K PRODUCTION (Arian Khoroushi)★★★☆☆
Here’s a balanced 3-star review that sounds fair and genuine:
★★★☆☆
Olio e Più has a great atmosphere and is a nice spot if you’re looking for a lively Italian restaurant. We came a little early specifically to try their happy hour menu.
Our server was very respectful, friendly, and attentive throughout our visit. The only thing I didn’t love was feeling a bit rushed to place our order before happy hour officially started. I understand why, but it made the experience feel a little more pressured than relaxed.
The bread and drinks were very good, but the food was a bit underwhelming. We tried the Focaccina Napoli and Caponatina, and while they were okay, neither dish really stood out or made me want to order them again.
At the end of the meal, I noticed that my mimosa had been charged a few dollars more than the price listed on the menu. I brought it to our server’s attention, and the manager came over, apologized, explained that it was due to a mix-up between their morning and evening menus, and immediately refunded the difference in cash.
Overall, the service and atmosphere were excellent, and I appreciated how professionally they handled the billing mistake. However, the food didn’t quite meet my expectations, which is why I’m giving it 3 stars.
Monteverde Restaurant & Pastificio

| Address | 1020 W Madison St, Chicago, IL 60607 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 10:30 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:30 PM
Sunday: Closed |
| Phone | (312) 888-3041 |
Stephanie★★★★★
You MUST get the burrata e ham full portion appetizer! This was my favorite part of the meal - salty from the prosciutto, prosciutto butter, and burrata and a slight hint of sweetness with the jam all on a fluffy bread.
The pastas were also delicious and good shareable portions. 10/10 understand why it’s so hard to get a last minute reservation here.
Owen M★★★★★
I came to celebrate my Birthday at Monteverde and would highly recommend. It was my first time here, mostly because it's hard to snag an online reservation and I obviously see why!
The service was very comforting and being able to watch the pasta making station was a great touch to the atmosphere. The FOOD was spectacular! We order what was highly recommended: Burrata e ham, cacio whey pepe, and the lasagna al forno. The lasagna was my favorite dish, but really everything was amazing, the fresh pasta and flavor combinations makes this place and their dishes so memorable.
Not only do they have some of the best pasta dishes in Chicago, do not skip out on their desserts! The tiramasu was amazing. I can write about all the flavors and dishes, but really you should try it out yourselves! Highly recommeded Chicago staple.
Vijay K★★★★★
Monteverde absolutely lived up to the hype. The Cacio e Pepe was perfectly executed with incredible flavor, and the Pomodoro Spaghetti showed how amazing simple, fresh ingredients can be. The Wagyu beef skewers were tender, flavorful, and cooked just right.
And whatever you do, beware the tiramisu. The portion is incredibly generous, but every bite is worth it. It’s rich, creamy, and the perfect way to end the meal.
The staff was warm, friendly, and attentive, making the entire lunch experience even more enjoyable. I would happily come back the next time I’m in Chicago.
Andrew Lim★★★★★
Great Italian restaurant located in the West Loop - Monteverde by Chef Sarah Grueneberg (former Top Chef contestant) focuses on delicate handmade Italian pastas and large hearty shareable mains. Some dishes signatures include the wagyu beef skewers and the massive ragu napoletana (huge pork neck, sausage and gremolata). Also be sure to save room for dessert such as the delicious lemon ice cake!
Reservations are notoriously hard to come by and will take a fair amount of persistence to book, but Monteverde is easily one of the best Italian restaurants in Chicago.
Dari’s Passport & Plate★★★★★
Worth every bit of the reservation struggle. I went during Restaurant Week and loved being able to sample a little bit of everything. The shrimp and potatoes were hands down my favorite; so flavorful and perfectly done.
The meatball was unbelievably tender, and the house made gnocchetti was outstanding. You can even watch them making the pasta, which makes the whole experience feel extra special. The tiramisu was simply amazing. Add in attentive, friendly service and it was a great experience all around. I’d absolutely come back.
Labriola Ristorante - Chicago

| Address | 535 N Michigan Ave, Chicago, IL 60611 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Phone | (312) 955-3100 |
Dave Olesczuk★★★★★
First time here and absolutely loved this place. Pizza and wine are two of my favorite things. The wine list was very good, lots of great wines to choose from to pair with your meal. The pizza was incredible - one of the best I have had. Light, flaky crust, great sauce and toppings. So good! Service was great! The outdoor patio was nice too. We had great weather that day so it was nice to sit outside and enjoy the city.
Robert Cardoni★★★★★
Wow … we were looking to try Chicago deep dish and tavern pies. And this place was the spot to try them. We did the thin pie with sausage and deep dish with burrata. The deep dish is a pan style - not stuffed. Absolutely amazing. Had enough to bring home in the flight and it was just as good reheated.
Karla Caban★★★★☆
It was a busy Saturday night. We waiting about 20 minutes for our table. We ordered the Rigatoni allá vodka and when we received our meal it was shells. I wasn’t sure if that was the correct dish, as the waiters seemed to be delivering the wrong items to 2 separate tables. Our waiters said it was correct and I said that it was shells and not rigatoni and he said oh yeah someone else said the same thing and kept walking! Fine, the sauce was really really flavorful! We enjoyed it very much and probably would come back for the pasta. Had read good reviews about their pizza and we ordered the Margherita Artisan pizza. The sauce was a bit sweet and we prefer savory. It just tasted like sweet tomato paste. Kind of burnt sauce. Not much flavor but the sweetness is what stuck out to both of us. Not our style of sauce but others probably enjoy this sweet yet acidic sauce. The drinks were ok, should have just ordered a beer. Not sure I’d be back, but glad I finally got to try it after so many years!
Candace★★★★★
Food was great! I'm not a big beef eater, I usually don't eat double burgers, but this one right here was delicious!!! The meat was cooked to perfection, juicy, moist, bun was soft, flavor was fresh really good, perfectly seasoned, the veggies were fresh. And the manager was a delight! Very positive friendly attitude.
Private Private★★★★★
Anthony A was an absolutely fantastic server! Great recommendations, great service. We had gluten free pizza and the GF shrimp alfredo pasta dish. Other guests got the deep dish! Love this place. No GF deserts, but we were too full anyway. 😀
Pizzeria Portofino

| Address | 317 N Clark St, Chicago, IL 60654 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday: 11:30 AM – 9:30 PM
Saturday: 11:30 AM – 9:30 PM
Sunday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM |
| Phone | (312) 900-9018 |
Melina Escareno★★★★★
We had been dying to try this restaurant for months and it did not disappoint! We had the pepperoni pizza with hot honey, garlic bread, Parmesan fries, and the Portofino Purse drink! All of our selections tasted amazing and were reasonably priced. This is definitely a must if you are out in Chicago. Our server was so sweet and attentive which made our experience even better.
Babes N Bladez★★★★★
Yep, gotta go! It’s not just a pizzeria but rather, it’s a great place to hang out, well rounded place with all walks of life! You can sit inside or outside right by the river! What a place!
Service, 5 star, all did amazing! Julia H was amazing!
You can watch all the tourism boats drive by, the best part is the group on board is waving to you like a bunch of wackos! Good times! Just wave back, no one will remember, many can’t swim. There are many yachts, nice ones - most rented for sure with strippers and pimps, and redneck pontoon rentals go by with, some of the best one piece bathing suits you’ll see, just wave!
Ok onto the food, amazing place to eat. The food is really good. All the pizzas were amazing, the appetizers that we got were just perfect. You couldn’t ask for a better meal on the river. Just remember to wave to the Chicago water taxi!
Reservation will save you time!
5 stars!
D Scheffler★★★★★
Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had!! We loved this place so much we went there two days in a row lol. The first time we had reservations and the second time we ordered to go and it was just as good. Drinks were tasty & strong. Super nice staff.
Larayna Gilmor★★★★★
If you are looking for the perfect view of the Chicago river and a perfect patio come here. The views are outstanding. The service is top notch. And the food is even better. The staff was so friendly and helpful and they even helped set up a birthday brunch for my friend. They made the day extra special. We ordered lots of different options from the menu and they were all delicious. Jacob was WONDERFUL!
Zach Schramm★★★★★
Pizzeria Portofino absolutely delivered from start to finish. I kicked things off with an espresso martini—fabulous and perfectly balanced. For appetizers, the prosciutto San Daniele was outstanding, and the Parmesan fries came out hot, fresh, and perfectly crispy.
For my main, I had the classic cacio e pepe, and it was everything you want it to be—simple, rich, and executed flawlessly. Dessert was the lemon tiramisu, and wow… I didn’t know I needed that in my life, but it completely hit the spot.
Jose was our server and did a fantastic job. Even with how busy the restaurant was, we never felt rushed, which made the experience even better.
Pro tip: reservations fill up fast, so book well in advance. We sat on the heated patio, and the views of the Chicago River were iconic—such a great touch that really elevated the whole evening.
The Village

| Address | 71 W Monroe St, Chicago, IL 60603 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM |
| Phone | (312) 332-7005 |
Brett Gottfried★★★★☆
Absolutely amazing atmosphere, you really feel like you are going back in time. They are one of the oldest Italian restaurants in Chicago. We got the cooked salmon which was perfect. The pizza was pretty good and the meat balls as well. If you go hear, I would stick the the pasta and cocktails, they are strong.
Michal Salach★★★★★
Third time visiting The Village and every experience delivers delicious food, outstanding staff, and a romantic/relaxed atmosphere that elevates the whole experience.
Starting with homemade mozzarella sticks, the quality cheese, great breading, and marinara go so well together. For the patient, coordinated, and slightly silly, the fresh mozzarella made for a quality cheese pull.
Tomato Panzanella is my new summer salad obsession. If you love tomatoes and cucumbers, don’t miss it.
Chicken broth and minestrone soups really send home the message they honor ‘low and slow’ cooking methods and breadth of flavor that come along with that patience and care.
Eggplant parm threaded the needle of a great crispy crust with plenty of flavor and moisture still in the eggplant. Tomato sauce and penne were also incredible. Basically two meals in one.
Take next bit of critique with grain of salt because I’ve never had risotto in Italy or really know what a perfect one should taste like. I wouldn’t reorder the specials menu saffron risotto and shrimp.
Not sure I could distinguish any saffron flavor but that could be my own palette’s fault. Mostly tasted lemon and a slight umami flavor, but that could’ve come from the broth? Shrimp well seasoned but would’ve like large gulf shrimp.
Still tasted good, just not a home run for me, and the range and quality of the rest of their menu I’ve had over three visits still earn the Village an easy 5 stars all around.
Would love to try a mushroom risotto with some cheese folded in to go on the side of a chicken dish.
Tiramisu ended dinner on a high note with great cream, coffee, and ladyfinger balance.
Even though I typically prefer trying new restaurants out when I visit cities, my fiancé and I have made so many good memories and experiences here, I have no doubt we’ll be returning for years to come.
J*AF★★★★★
We came at the off-hour of 3pm. It was quiet and minimally occupied. We had El as our server and he was fabulous. Knew his stuff, a d knew how to attend a table. We didn't request a private room and because the place was so empty, we're glad we didn't... Had it been peak hour, we would have like one though.
Food was exactly what we were looking for. A hearty bite, with leftovers for later. Meatballs were great, meat ravioli with arrabiata sauce was delish and pretty spicy. Garlic bread was delicious. Veal parmigiana was fabulous. Pitcher of sangria was soooooo good! Try them all. We loved the small stairway going up to the second floor to this restaurant. It's beautiful and quaint.
John Etrheim★★★★☆
The lasagna was the best I’ve ever had! That alone is worth 5 stars. ⭐️ The wait staff was friendly, but we did feel a little rushed during our meal.
We would definitely come back to eat here again. The reason for the 4-star rating is the accessibility issue getting to the upstairs dining area (see photo).
Megan Mulholland★★★★★
My friend and I came here, Chicago’s oldest Italian restaurant, for dinner. We didn’t have a reservation but they found a seat for us. The village and authentic Italian ambiance was such fun. Some people were eating in little “cottages.” Our service was good and my meal was yummy. My friend said hers was fine. It was fun to learn about the history.
Piccolo Sogno

| Address | 464 N Halsted St, Chicago, IL 60642 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 10:30 PM
Saturday: 4:00 – 10:30 PM
Sunday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (312) 421-0077 |
Liz Perez★★★★★
Beautiful dinner date spot! The place is beautiful, and as soon as we walked in we were greeted with the kindest smiles. Our server was also very nice and helpful. They weren’t too busy so service was pretty quick, which worked out perfectly since we were in a bit of a rush. The pasta was amazing. Can’t wait to go back and enjoy their drinks next time.
Swati Sharma★★★★★
Absolutely loved this Italian restaurant in Chicago! The pasta was hands down one of the best I’ve had—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The drinks were also amazing and complemented the meal really well. The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. We especially enjoyed the outdoor seating—it had such a nice vibe. Highly recommend this place if you’re looking for great Italian food and a relaxing atmosphere!
karina k★★★★★
Atmosphere like home, food done just right, veg choices, nice ambience and good pasta choices...
Friendly staff and valet parking for an extra fee. The CTA blue line grand Station is right here as well as the bus. Very convenient. The dessert called Panna Cotta de Limone was very silky and a few tiny pieces of candied orange peel on top to offset the smooth flan like fluffy sweet. It's very tasty and not too sweet.
Beth Jones★★★★★
Excellent service. Ate at the bar, was greeted and served immediately by a friendly and knowledgeable bartender. Didnt get a picture of the prosciutto appetizer but its a hefty portion. Ravioli picollo sogno was great. Dessert was the panna cotta which was ethereal. Had some limoncello to top it all off. 10/10
_aliased★★★★★
Visited during Restaurant Week 2026 with work colleagues. Went in expecting to be overly critical, and comparing the food to meals in Rome… and came away pleasantly surprised.
Aperol spritz availability, but not on menu. Rich and flavorful pasta, but with an Americanized twist (utilizing roast beef stew in my dish inlew of sausage). Appetizers and pizza was enjoyable, the buttered house bread was a crowd pleaser. Some of our party had minor complaints around the freshness of the pasta, but didn’t bleed into my appreciation.
Additionally, a very affordable experience comparing base prices to Rome. Felt just like an ideal Italian family restaurant.
La Scarola

| Address | 721 W Grand Ave, Chicago, IL 60654 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 5:00 – 11:00 PM
Wednesday: 5:00 – 11:00 PM
Thursday: 5:00 – 11:00 PM
Friday: 5:00 – 11:00 PM
Saturday: 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Sunday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (312) 243-1740 |
One Persons Opinion★★★★☆
WOW...
This place was just wow..
Old school service with food that feels stright out of the 50s/60s... 💯% Italian American flavor with a touch of Goodfellas.
Members of my family both had pasta dishes, both amazing.. Myself, I had the meat lasagna, personally I wouldn't order it again.
I'm definitely going back..
Oh the Cannoli ehh...
ali chung★★★★★
A True Old-School Italian Gem!
We had a fabulous meal at La Scarola on West Grand this evening, and it fully lived up to its reputation as a classic Chicago Italian restaurant. Celebrating nearly 30 years, this place has that perfect energetic, lively atmosphere with wonderful old-school vibes — exactly what you hope for in a neighborhood Italian spot.
We started with the grilled octopus, which was tender and delicious. For our entrees, the chilean sea bass was outstanding, and the Penne alla Vodka (with shrimp, mushrooms, asparagus, and arugula in a creamy vodka sauce) was rich and perfectly executed. We finished with vanilla sorbet, a refreshing end to a fantastic meal.
The service was great — they are attentive and friendly without being overbearing — and the entire environment felt warm, bustling, and full of life. The food was genuinely delicious from start to finish. In a city full of Italian options, La Scarola stands out as the real deal.
Highly recommend making a reservation (they only take them by phone) and treating yourself to a memorable dinner here. We’ll definitely be back!
Mike M★★★★★
All of the food was amazing, as well as the drinks and the service. Hard to pick our favorites but we really liked the gnocchi, the veal chop was great, and the rigatoni with vodka sauce was delicious. Also the octopus was unreal. Overall, everything was a big hit and will definitely be back. Would definitely recommend!
Noel Burt★★★★★
I highly recommend calling to get a reservation since it can get very busy and would require a long wait. We had the best Italian food I have ever had! We had the bruschetta that was well seasoned, light and crisp, pasta Mandera (which I didn’t get a picture of) but was beyond tasty and perfectly cooked! The creamy vodka sauce tastes delicious and this dish has a hit of garlic that sits well! I got the Panne Alla vodka which had a perfect ratio of shrimp, mushroom and asparagus. Although it initially seemed heavy the asparagus was a great pallet cleanser. There was a special that we had tried that was a variation of a carbonara that was are least favorite out of the three just due to the intense garlic taste and a sauce that was a little to thin. All of it tasted delicious over all and we will definitely be back! It was great to see the meals others ordered! They had big helpings that were great as left overs the next day! This can be pricy but I would say worth it. If you like a white wine their New Zealand Sauvignon blanc was lite and fruity that completed well.
Reese★★★★★
The food was really good! The portions are huge so definitely need to share it! The inside is kind of small and very busy. I can see why this place is so popular! You’ll need to call to make a resy. I do not recommend walking in.
Siena Tavern

| Address | 51 W Kinzie St, Chicago, IL 60654 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM
Thursday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM
Friday: 11:30 AM – 12:00 AM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (312) 471-1636 |
david wilson★★★★★
For us, Siena Tavern is like an oasis in the middle of the city. The space is huge. They've got a beautiful outdoor patio, a massive wraparound bar, a cocktail area, and a pizza bar. They really designed the place so you can relax instead of feeling packed in shoulder to shoulder.
The food is consistently good. Every visit has been excellent. The portions are generous, and more importantly, tastes great.
The service is five star. The staff is genuinely attentive and engaged, and the happy hour is one of the most generous in the city.
It's been a River North local favorite for years. For happy hour, pizza, or a full dinner, it's a place that's easy to recommend and one we keep going back to.
Lynn Findlay★★★★★
We had a great experience at Siena Tavern. We sat outside and enjoyed the gorgeous weather. We shared the diablo pizza 🍕 drizzled with hot honey, so yummy. The inside of the restaurant is beautiful. It has a great vibe. I would highly recommend!
Rachel Vk★★★★★
Not an exaggeration by any means, but the Rigatoni Alla Vodka I’ve eaten here is quite possibly one of the best pasta dishes I’ve eaten anywhere in the world. That sauce is worth a king’s ransom. We also ate the pancakes, chicken sandwich and the kale salad and everything was lovely.
Our server Daniela was courteous, friendly and helpful. Would definitely go back! Best Italian fare in town
Monet Felton★★★★☆
Great Happy Hour. Definitely some hits and misses with the food. Wasn’t impressed with the arancini or the mini tavern burger. Would definitely reorder the sea-bass Milanese. The pizza was pizza nothing special. The strawberry spritz was on the sweeter side for sure but yummy. The martini was yummy and I was obsessed with their blue cheese olives. And for two we spent under $115. Definitely returning.
Jessica Acuna★★★★★
Every plate was beyond amazing. I went during resturants week so the portions were smaller from what they usually serve in order to try the full course. I tried a bit of the octopus and I must come back for it again! It was extremely tender and balanced with different flavors. The waygu meatball was juicy and melted in your mouth. 10 out of 10 for all the items I tried.
Gibsons Italia

| Address | 233 N Canal St, Chicago, IL 60606 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM |
| Phone | (312) 414-1100 |
Heather Steinmiller★★★★★
What an incredible experience! Such a gorgeous view to go along with the excellent dinner. I finally got to try the famous Roman fried artichokes à la Giudia (sp?) and they were phenomenal. So crispy, crunchy, and delicious. The focaccia was fresh out of the oven, and the fried Brussels sprouts melted in the mouth. My filet mignon was perfectly cooked, and the Béarnaise sauce was awesome. My husband raved about his Chilean sea bass, and our two other dining companions were equally enthusiastic about their choices. I had the sorbet trio for dessert - tart, tangy, and bursting with flavors of raspberry, lemon, and mango. Not a banana fan myself, but it disappeared as quickly as my sorbets did. Service was fantastic all around - everybody worked together and it was a delight to watch. Plus the rooftop view was a definite plus. Absolutely make a reservation here!
Erick Candelas★★★★★
We had a wonderful experience at Gibsons Italia, and a huge part of that was the incredible service.
Zachary was fantastic from start to finish. He was extremely knowledgeable about the menu, took the time to explain different options, and gave us recommendations that were genuinely spot-on. He was attentive without ever being overbearing, professional, welcoming, and incredibly hospitable. You can tell he really understands the menu and knows how to guide guests toward the right choices.
A special shoutout as well to Graham behind the bar. Graham has an awesome personality and brings such great energy to the experience. He was personable, engaging, and clearly knows his craft. The drinks were beautifully made, balanced, and executed with real attention to detail. Beyond making great cocktails, he made the bar feel warm and inviting—the kind of bartender who can read the room, have a great conversation, and make you feel like a regular even if it’s your first visit.
Between Zachary’s hospitality and Graham’s personality and cocktail skills, the service truly elevated the entire experience. Gibsons Italia already has an incredible setting and menu, but people like Zachary and Graham are what make you want to come back.
Absolutely outstanding experience. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Mahshid Zandian★★★★★
• Beautiful atmosphere with a great vibe.
• Excellent service from start to finish.
• The food quality was outstanding.
• We ordered the Australian Ribeye and the scallop risotto. The ribeye was perfectly cooked, flavorful, and high quality. The risotto was rich, creamy, unique, and topped with five large scallops.
• The layered cake-and-ice-cream dessert was also outstanding and the perfect way to end the meal.
• The patio is a great option as well.It’s first come first serve.
Everything we ordered was delicious and clearly made with high-quality ingredients.
A couple of small notes: the risotto portion felt a little smaller than expected, and while the ribeye came with roasted garlic and onion, I would have loved to see a few more vegetables on the side.
Definitely make a reservation — this place gets very busy.🙌🏼
Ed Brill★★★★★
Stopped in on a Sunday to grab a drink and some apps. The bar area is huge and at least when we arrived, there were plenty of hi-tops available. A great room, lots of openness, of course the view is fantastic as well.
Service was at the Gibson's level of excellence but even a step above that. Our server was very attentive, conversational, knowledgeable, and helpful. Food-wise, this steak tartare was the prettiest I have ever seen, both plating as well as the flourish of smoke as it was served.
Cocktails were delicious and on brand. Good wines by the glass.
Reasonable pricing given the view and setting and quality.
Will be back!
Maximillion Frommelt★★★★★
Between being treated immediately, having multiple staff check in, and having out of this world food; you get every cent worth from Gibsons! The charged octopus was perfectly balanced between smokiness and umami and is a must have. The risotto was delicate and had a huge flavor profile. As someone who likes to nitpick, I honestly can find a single thing wrong. Bravo and this is easily worth a stop if you are near Chicago.
Adalina Italian

| Address | 912 N State St, Chicago, IL 60610 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Tuesday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Wednesday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Thursday: 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Friday: 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Saturday: 3:00 – 11:00 PM
Sunday: 3:00 – 10:00 PM |
| Phone | (312) 820-9000 |
ericaswipes★★★★★
Three of us went for Happy Hour during the World Cup so it was a very different vibe than typical I should think (there are TVs in the bar area). We still had great service from the warm greeting at the host stand, to our attentive server and friendly food, water and drink runners. The HH specials are very good for both the food and drink. There’s a nice multiple choice drink bite main option as well. Shrimp and oysters were very fresh (with excellent horseradish) and the gnocchi fritti were great. Fries that came with caprese slider could’ve been crisper but I’m sure that was a stylistic choice on their part. We were very happy with everything and will definitely make a point to return.
Peaking into the main dining area, it looked art deco glam yet comfortable— definitely a special occasion kind of place that you would want to dress for. Though in sure you’d be made to feel welcome however you came in.
The individual WC’s were brightly lit, had their own sinks, good quality TP, no cosmetic or hygiene products and super cool holographic-type wallpaper that made me want to redecorate at home!
HH food/drink: A bathroom B+ overall: A-
Tonia★★★★☆
First visit to Adalina and we loved it! We tried the Sunday Supper Prix Fixe, and there was more than enough food for our table, plus leftovers to take home. We also added the steak and potatoes, which were delicious.
We didn't realize until later that we never received the meatballs included with the meal, but honestly, there was so much food we forgot to mention it.
The service was outstanding. We were celebrating a birthday, and the staff was determined to keep the candle lit despite the breeze from the open windows.
Great food, beautiful atmosphere, and attentive service. We'll definitely be back!
Lana T★★★★☆
This place is so nice and perfect for celebrating a friends birthday. We waited more than half and hour to be seated but overall the food was really good. Got their lamb bolognese and it had so much flavors.
Their bread service was good was well. I loved how they have rotating sorbet to try and the tiramisu was really good and creamy. Loved how everything was decorated for Christmas.
Muhammad Fariz Ali★★★★☆
We came for a birthday it is a really nice atmosphere upscale and lively. The scallops were good but nothing extra ordrinary too much bread crumbs. The pasta was alright the pasta itself was well done but the flavor was missing more depth it felt like something you could get for a lot cheaper. The citrus waygu was fantastic def great tenderness and flavor worth coming here for it. The tiramisu was also good as was the ice cream. Overall worth coming here would try some other dishes. They were very considerate gave us the ice cream for free
Ferhat Han★★★★★
Great experience! Celebrated my wife's birthday here and everything was spot on. The staff was very professional and caring, and the food was amazing. The place has a very sophisticated vibe. We really enjoyed our evening and will definitely be back. Thanks for the great service!
Francesca's On Chestnut

| Address | 200 E Chestnut St, Chicago, IL 60611 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11:30 AM – 9:30 PM
Tuesday: 11:30 AM – 9:30 PM
Wednesday: 11:30 AM – 9:30 PM
Thursday: 11:30 AM – 9:30 PM
Friday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 11:30 AM – 9:30 PM |
| Phone | (312) 482-8800 |
Noah Sullivan★★★★★
I could not have chosen a better place for a meal. From the moment we arrived, everything was fantastic. The service was outstanding, and the staff made us feel welcome while ensuring we had a great experience from start to finish.
The food was absolutely delicious and arrived fresh, hot, and beautifully prepared. Every dish was full of flavor and clearly made with care. Between the excellent service and the quality of the food, it was an amazing dining experience that exceeded expectations. I would happily return again.
Daniel Segar★★★★★
I came here for my birthday because the staff is always so nice to me and my family. I usually come here for drinks after work or any celebration. The food is delicious consistently on point. It is my go to for Italian food in Chicago. The service is attentive and friendly. Rachel and Ben handled our large party with ease and made us feel like their favorite family to serve. The GM, Michael helped us with the reservation and our menu making the entire experience feel smoother than a cruise down Lake Shore Drive.
We love this place!
Big Ern★★★★★
We had one of the best experiences dinning at Francesca’s On Chestnut. It started right when we entered early for our reservation and we were accommodated immediately. We were brought downstairs to the wine cellar and the atmosphere was intimate and authentic. Our servers and runners were amazing making small conversations singing along with the playlist and overall enjoying their job. The food was incredible. We had the linguine with clams and chicken milanese. The team put on the World Cup game and did not mind when we sat after dinner and had a few more drinks to watch the beginning of the game. They have been in business for 30+ years and I understand why. Phenomenal food, immaculate service and an overall delight of a dinning experience. We want to explore more of the city but we also want to try more of the menu. In a city that has a ton of great restaurants, this should be on your list to try.
Verlycia Dixon★★★★★
When I tell you best food I've eaten in a while....
The bolognes was top tier. The chicken fell off the bone. The food looked add if it would be greasy and heavy but it was so light and fresh. Seasoned perfectly with herbs and spices; NOT SALT! The only thing about the food I would change is the bread. I would like a softer bread that sopped up the oil better. The service was great. The waiter was able to tell us about each dish from the experiences of other guests.
Lukas Taylor★★★★★
Wow wow wow. First of all Tiffany was the best waiter I have ever encountered, she gave us the best recommendations and made our night. We went out here for Valentine’s Day and it was just amazing. Great quality food that makes you want to come back next week. Can’t recommend this place enough for a great date night. Highly recommend the risotto as an appetizer and the steak or pollo Milanese for your main.
Ciccio Mio

| Address | 226 W Kinzie St, Chicago, IL 60654 |
| Maps | Click here |
| Website | Click here |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 4:00 – 10:30 PM
Tuesday: 4:00 – 10:30 PM
Wednesday: 4:00 – 10:30 PM
Thursday: 4:00 – 10:30 PM
Friday: 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Saturday: 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Sunday: 4:00 – 10:30 PM |
| Phone | (312) 796-3316 |
Madison Gaudencio★★★★★
10/10 experience. Cole was an EXCELLENT server. Super attentive to the table and knowledgeable to all things food and wine! We started with the focaccia and whipped ricotta which was delicious. For our mains, my mom and I split the ricotta gnocchi and the carbonara. The gnocchi was bursting with flavor!! It basically melted in your mouth. The carbonara was also delicious and cooked perfectly. My dad got the short rib which was also amazing. For dessert, we got the tiramisu and it was of course, delicious. I got an espresso martini which I thought to be okay but I also never get espresso martinis without baileys so I know for next time. Lastly, the restaurant is super cute and cozy, it’s perfect!
Ashley C★★★★★
Ciccio Mio truly exceeded my expectations! We sat on the patio and it was perfect for a relaxing dinner. Our waitress was absolutely amazing: friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed throughout the evening.
The food was incredible, with every dish full of flavor and beautifully presented. Everything was top-notch. Highly Recommend!
Alessandro Pedicelli★★★★★
We had a delicious meal here while in Chicago for work. The service is super attentive and the room is stunning. Really gives you old school American Italian vibes, a place your nonno would love! We started with the Caesar salad, polenta, and meatballs and they were all bangers. Pastas were all tasty as well, vodka rigatoni was a hit. Finally we had the veal parm and it was great, perfectly cooked with a good balance of cheese and sauce. We will definitely be back!
Muhammad Fariz Ali★★★★★
Waited quite a while to get seated with a reservation, they were upfront with us, they do have valet which is not complimentary. The atmosphere is really unique and cozy it’s a great vibe. The food is was really good and the ricotta gnocchi was the best unique texture and the filling was very smooth. The truffle pasta was also a unique pasta well seasoned. The vodka rigatoni was a great classic can’t go wrong. My favorite dish was the pavlova it was a very good dessert filled with different flavors of sweet and tangy with different textures overall a good place to visit albeit the wait time was quite extended despite our reservation. Worth the visit.
Michael Carter★★★★★
Ciccio Mio gave us an unforgettable dining experience. Every single dish, from the rich, comforting pasta to the perfectly cooked mains, was flawless. The attention to detail and ingredient quality is top-notch. The restaurant has this beautifully warm, dim-lit atmosphere that made our night even more special. The wine pairing was a perfect match, and the service was highly professional. One of the top spots in Chicago for sure.
Tips for Choosing the Perfect Italian Restaurant in Chicago
Selecting the right restaurant often depends on understanding the subtle differences between Italian dining styles. Before you make a reservation, consider the type of experience you want, as Chicago offers everything from quick-service slice shops to multi-hour tasting menus. The following tips will help you match your cravings and budget to the right venue, ensuring your meal is exactly what you hoped for.
1. Understand the Difference Between Northern and Southern Italian Cuisine
Chicago has deep roots in Southern Italian immigration, which is why traditional "red sauce" joints are so prevalent. However, the modern scene has expanded to embrace Northern Italian cooking, which relies heavily on butter, risotto, and polenta rather than tomato sauce and olive oil. Check the menu before you go: if you see heavy cream and truffles, it is likely Northern; if you see San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella, you are in the South.
2. Don’t Overlook the "Secondi"
Many diners fill up on appetizers and pasta, missing out on the main courses. In high-end Italian dining, the secondi—meat and fish dishes—are often where the chef’s technique truly shines. Look for restaurants that offer whole branzino, veal chops, or slow-roasted porchetta. These dishes demonstrate a mastery of protein that goes beyond boiling water.
3. Check the Pasta Making Process
The best restaurants in Chicago take pride in their pasta program. Look for keywords like "house-made," "hand-rolled," or "extruded in-house" on the menu. Fresh pasta has a silkier texture that pairs beautifully with delicate sauces, while dried pasta (often imported from Gragnano) is superior for hearty ragùs. A great restaurant will know which type of flour and egg ratio to use for each specific shape.
4. Consider the Wine List’s Regional Focus
An authentic Italian restaurant will often feature a wine list that leans heavily on Italian varietals like Nebbiolo, Sangiovese, and Aglianico. If the list is dominated by California Cabernets, the restaurant may be prioritizing profit margins over culinary authenticity. Ask the sommelier or server for a wine that pairs with the specific region of Italy your dish originates from.
5. Look for the "Neighborhood Vibe" vs. "Special Occasion" Balance
Chicago’s best Italian food isn’t always found behind a velvet rope. Some of the most memorable meals happen in cramped dining rooms where the noise level is high and the garlic bread is endless. Conversely, if you are celebrating an anniversary, you may want a quieter room with impeccable service. Read recent reviews to gauge the noise level and pacing of the meal to ensure it aligns with your goals.
6. Don’t Sleep on the Pizza Styles
Italian restaurants in Chicago are not just about pasta. The city is home to a vibrant Neapolitan pizza scene (soft, charred, and soupy in the middle) as well as Roman-style pizza al taglio (square, crispy, and sold by weight). If you are dining with picky eaters, choosing a restaurant with a wood-fired oven often provides a safe and delicious fallback option.
7. Check the Bread and Olive Oil Program
It is a small detail, but the bread service often sets the tone for the entire meal. A restaurant that serves crusty, airy sourdough with high-quality, peppery olive oil is signaling that they care about the details. If the bread is cold or the oil is bland, it may be a sign that the kitchen cuts corners elsewhere.
Exploring Chicago’s Italian restaurants is a journey that can take months, if not years, to complete properly. Every neighborhood offers a different interpretation of the cuisine, shaped by the generations who settled there and the modern chefs who are pushing boundaries. Whether you are a tourist looking for the quintessential deep-dish experience or a local searching for a new favorite tagliatelle, the city delivers.
Ultimately, the best Italian meal is one shared with people you love, accompanied by good wine and lively conversation. These restaurants provide the backdrop for memories, offering comfort, warmth, and a sense of belonging that transcends the food on the plate. Buon appetito!